Keith Dunnavant

I had the pleasure of living in the Bay Area in the transition of Bill Walsh and Joe Montana making the 49ers one of football's super dynasties. It was a magical time back then and all that success sprouting from all that history of defeat. The debates that rage over who was the best quarterback of all time I think is rather pointless. Each of the greats did great things for their era and it should be left at that.

This book covers the career of one of those greats and it is quite a story. I would have liked a bit more focus on his personal life than the detailed play by play it went into. But on balance it covered Joe well and uncovered some of the difficult things he dealt with. One thing that can never be debated about Montana was the value of his quiet understated leadership and ability to deliver.… (més)

Most sports fans, particularly of the NFL variety, are going to be fairly biased about bios or books relating to their team. Certainly having grown up with Green Bay Packers and still remembering those black and white images on TV of Vince Lombardi stalking the sideline in 1963 I am no different. This book does a great job telling that story centered around this iconic figure Bart Starr. It was interesting in doing a search to enter this book into my library here a title came up, "Johnny Unitas, America's Quarterback." So the debate will never end. The thing this book brings out about Starr is despite the repeated second tier ranking many give him over the years, when you look at his performance year in and year out he really was always at or near the top, backed up by 5 Championships. But what cannot always be captured by titles and statistics is the character of the man and the leadership qualities. Something we don't see as much in today's sports arena, yet this man had in spades.… (més)