Imatge de l'autor

Marjorie Garber

Autor/a de Shakespeare after All

29+ obres 2,579 Membres 28 Ressenyes 4 preferits

Sobre l'autor

Marjorie Garber is William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of English and of Visual and Environmental Studies at Harvard University. Her many books include Loaded Words (Fordham); Symptoms of Culture; Quotation Marks; Shakespeare After All; Vested Interests: Cross-Dressing and Cultural Anxiety; and The Use mostra'n més and Abuse of Literature. mostra'n menys
Crèdit de la imatge: Photo by Jodi Hilton, for the New York Times

Obres de Marjorie Garber

Shakespeare after All (2005) 750 exemplars
Shakespeare and Modern Culture (2008) 150 exemplars
The Use and Abuse of Literature (2011) 121 exemplars
Dog Love (1996) 92 exemplars
Academic Instincts (2001) 87 exemplars
Shakespeare's ghost writers (1987) 52 exemplars
Symptoms of Culture (1998) 50 exemplars
The Medusa Reader (Culture Work) (2003) — Editor — 43 exemplars
Patronizing the Arts (2008) 35 exemplars
Quotation Marks (2002) 34 exemplars

Obres associades

Hamlet (1603)algunes edicions33,079 exemplars
Les Vides dels animals (1999) — Col·laborador — 616 exemplars
The Lesbian and Gay Studies Reader (1993) — Col·laborador — 410 exemplars
Lieutenant Nun: Memoir of a Basque Transvestite in the New World (1829) — Pròleg, algunes edicions350 exemplars
Staging the Renaissance (1991) — Col·laborador — 76 exemplars
Shakespeare and the editorial tradition (1999) — Col·laborador — 3 exemplars

Etiquetat

Coneixement comú

Membres

Ressenyes

Really rather good, although - as with so many books of this type - its target audience is a little ... vague.

In terms of accessibility for a general reader, Garber gives us a neat precis of Shakespeare's life and times, followed by analyses of all the plays in the canon. No play misses out, and all are treated fairly. At the same time, this is not an "introduction to Shakespeare", no matter what the blurb may try to sell you. All of the chapters assume at least some familiarity with the play in question, or are obscure enough about plot that you'd need to have some detail to begin with. This is not an account of the play's sources, history, or fate on the stage and screen; it's a popular academic treatise. With that said, if you're building up an amateur's Shakespeare library, this is an interesting read. What may be frustrating is an inevitability: there is so much to talk about with each play that, like most books of "essays", Garber tends to pick a few points about each play and then discuss them. This is not anything like a comprehensive overview (after all, most chapters are about 30 pages), but it tackles some of the key questions academics and directors ask about each work.

For the academic reader, I'm not sure how I feel. It seems as if Garber got the commission for the book by promising a general introduction, but she can't quite keep her intelligence at bay. And, hey, I'm not complaining; her insights are valid and well-written. Unlike most Shakespeare writers, I almost never feel as if she's wandering down a rabbit-hole of philosophical ramblings. No, Garber's analyses are - although decidedly deskbound - certainly drawn from real examination of the plays in the context of William Shakespeare's time. There are a few niggles depending on your taste (for me, I dislike that old-school scholar thing of describing a character using dashes, e.g. "Lear is her father-king"), but each to their own.

The challenge is that I'm not sure if the book unites the two worlds very well. Some of the chapters are quite high-minded, and reveal little to the general reader about the play. At the same time, there were very few surprises in the book for me (and thus, I'd assume, even fewer for the full-time Shakespeare academic). It doesn't seem as if Garber is really adding to the hefty discussion on the Bard, but nor is she a Richard Dawkins, able to illuminate a fascinating-but-niche world for the general public.

I should note this is a positive review, indeed a 5-star review (well, 4.6) - in part because I admire Garber's writing, her intelligence, and her views, and in part because as a Shakespeare lover, I was engaged on every single damn page. I heartily recommend this book to people in an "in-between" stage of Shakespeare scholarship, but I'd champion the great populists like Stephen Greenblatt and Stanley Wells for those looking to get their head around the plays in an intellectual-but-understandable way.
… (més)
 
Marcat
therebelprince | Hi ha 10 ressenyes més | Apr 21, 2024 |
Garber, Marjorie. Shakespeare After All. Anchor, 2005.
I have been reading at Shakespeare After All for almost a year—a chapter now and then, especially if I had a chance to read or view one of the plays. So, I may have missed any general argument Marjorie Garber was making. But play by play, the discussions were engaging and insightful. She was especially good on Lear and Anthony and Cleopatra. One reviewer compared the book to the work of A. C. Bradley. Yes, but of course much more current. 4 stars.… (més)
 
Marcat
Tom-e | Hi ha 10 ressenyes més | Apr 1, 2023 |
Word to the wise, have a dictonary handy when reading this one. Althought I liked the premise, the idea that the value of literature is in the questions it asks and the thinking in requires, I felt she wandered around quite a bit. I found that she expected a basis of knowledge that many a lay person would not have. I just wish spoke to her intended audience, the lay reader, in a less formal, academic way.
 
Marcat
Colleen5096 | Hi ha 4 ressenyes més | Oct 29, 2020 |
Bisexuality in literature, history, boarding schools, psychology, biology... This book makes the invisible and marginialized visible. Every chapter added more to my list of books I need to read (and I've even gotten around to a few of them). It's definitely one I mean to re-read; I suffered informational overload the first time through.
1 vota
Marcat
akaGingerK | Hi ha 3 ressenyes més | Sep 30, 2018 |

Llistes

Premis

Potser també t'agrada

Autors associats

Estadístiques

Obres
29
També de
8
Membres
2,579
Popularitat
#9,966
Valoració
4.1
Ressenyes
28
ISBN
112
Llengües
4
Preferit
4

Gràfics i taules