Carl Hart (1)

I read DRUG USE FOR GROWNUPS before reading this; if I had read this first, I think I would have been surprised to read the second. This is Dr. Hart's memoir. Throughout his youth and young adulthood, we feel him just floating above the surface of drug use - just a little marijuana and alcohol, very little, with his athletic performance as an excuse. And a little cocaine later. He doesn't seem really into any of it. So what a surprise to find him an unapologetic heroin hobbyist in the second book. His overall message is the same - drugs don't ruin lives, people ruin lives; it's just that I really wouldn't have pegged him for a user.

I do love a life story and I enjoyed his memoir. It did give an interesting perspective on life and problems in "the hood". Hart grew up with five older sisters and two younger brothers; an alcoholic father, eventually separated parents. He witnessed crime, addiction, abuse; he shoplifted, he fathered a child he didn't know about for 16 years. He also played basketball and joined the military, and from there it's a story of life turned around.… (més)

This is an important book. Anyone who thinks "drugs are bad" covers the whole topic really ought to read this book. The nuance and personal experiences, and the thoughtful and science-based lessons, are critical to increasing understanding of who abuses drugs and why, and what should be done. Unilaterally criminalizing Does Not Work, and directly damages us socially, politically, and economically.

I think it needed more editing. I found it somewhat repetitive. I think it would have had more punch had Dr. Hart's personal experiences rambled less; there are very important lessons that get buried in excess verbiage (to steal a term from "Twice Upon a Time".) That said, I am grateful to have read it!… (més)

I saw Dr. Carl Hart speak in Grand Rapids, Mich., and was impressed by his thoughtfulness about how our drug policies impact the poorest and most under-served in our population, and completely agreed that the drug policy that leads to mass incarceration for non-violent offenders needs to change. Dr. Hart is a neuro-psychologist who pulled himself up out of a risk-laden environment and who is succeeding wonderfully as the first African-American tenured neuroscientist at Columbia University. I applaud that. I did feel that the science part of the discussion was missing from his talk, and then found that his book was shelved in the biography section of the library, when I was expecting to see it in the science area. After reading it, I agree, it belongs in the biography section. It's mostly memoir, with some discussion of Dr. Hart's studies and behavioral experiments thrown in. While I agree with his social premises, I was underwhelmed with the writing and the content of the book. I'm going to try some other books that address the topic of mass incarceration to try and figure out if it's just me, or if there are more clear and commanding arguments out there. 2 1/2 Stars.… (més)