Imatge de l'autor

Aaron James (1)

Autor/a de Assholes: A Theory

Per altres autors anomenats Aaron James, vegeu la pàgina de desambiguació.

4 obres 760 Membres 20 Ressenyes

Sobre l'autor

Aaron James is Professor of Philosophy at the University of California, Irvine.

Obres de Aaron James

Etiquetat

Coneixement comú

Membres

Ressenyes

Doubleday, which published this book, appears to have seen an opportunity to move some units by wrapping the book in a dust jacket that makes it look like a humor book on the order of, say, Justin Halpern's amusing Sh*t My Dad Says. As several disappointed reviewers in this forum have pointed out, A**holes: A Theory (please forgive the asterisks; I have a G-rated gravatar), isn't that kind of book. It's author, Aaron James, holds a doctorate in philosophy from Harvard; he is on the faculty of the University of California at Irvine. So, this is, in fact, a relatively serious work of philosophy. I use the qualifier relatively, because I imagine Mr. James' colleagues in the academy, at least some of them, would find it difficult to take seriously a philosophical treatise whose title is a barnyard epithet. That said, Mr. James is very clear that this is a work of "pop philosophy," similar to Harry Frankfort's On Bullsh*t (Mr. James cites On Bullsh*t a few times in his text). I rather doubt that either of these scholars shopped these manuscripts around for peer review and journal publication. They're very clear with their readers what these books are and are about.

In any case, I assume for everyone reading this, life has afforded them plenty of opportunity to deal with the personality type this tome's title defines. Chances are good, moreover, that readers of this book have on more than one occasion used this, uh, term of art, either in casual conversation or in abject frustration, to designate an offensive person in their midst.

Mr. James' philosophical project in this book--and he has his tongue at least partially in his cheek as he carries this out--is to determine the fundamental characteristics of a**holes. That accomplished, he continues in a discursive analysis about why the a**hole is so offensive that we find it necessary to, well, freight him or her with such an unfortunately evocative noun.

Needless to say, the book's title makes appearances as many if not most of the parts of speech, sometimes with suffixes--e.g. "a**holish," an adjective I favor in moments of irritation. In some respects, the repetition of the word distracts from, but doesn't attenuate, the force of Mr. James' argument. I did find myself wondering if the book would convey more gravitas if a different term, something perhaps more clinical or scholarly, were used to describe this type of challenging personality.

However, to reiterate, this is a work of pop philosophy (interestingly, if you search the term on the internet, one of the first things to pop up is the Wikipedia entry on "pseudophilosophy"). So the title is probably apt. I don't mean, in emphasizing this relatively new genre--since I don't think professional philosophers would like hearing it called a "new scholarly field"--to diminish this book. There is serious analysis as work here, and Mr. James is a fine stylist who conveys complicated ideas without trivializing them. Anyone who deals with difficult people (as Mr. James points out several times, a**holes are everywhere) will probably find salubrious the stoic approach Mr. James counsels in dealing with them.
… (més)
 
Marcat
Mark_Feltskog | Hi ha 16 ressenyes més | Dec 23, 2023 |
I started this book but I did not like the writing style very much and I had other stuff to read so I gave it back to the library. The writing seemed scrambled, with the paragraphs not in the right order. I agree with reviewer MikeMonje that there is too much surfing and not enough Sartre.
 
Marcat
Dokfintong | Hi ha 1 ressenya més | Aug 28, 2022 |
Dry and philosophical read, not funny. I trudged through the first chapter and got no further.
 
Marcat
BritishKoalaTea | Hi ha 16 ressenyes més | Mar 1, 2022 |
This book gives one a lot to think about.

A reader with at least a passing knowledge is philosophy will get more out of the book than if one has never read Descartes, Kant or Neitchze. The author refers to these and other more obscure philosophers throughout the book.
 
Marcat
Chrissylou62 | Hi ha 16 ressenyes més | Aug 1, 2020 |

Potser també t'agrada

Autors associats

Estadístiques

Obres
4
Membres
760
Popularitat
#33,470
Valoració
3.1
Ressenyes
20
ISBN
29
Llengües
4

Gràfics i taules