Foto de l'autor
10 obres 153 Membres 2 Ressenyes

Obres de David Monaghan

Etiquetat

Coneixement comú

Membres

Ressenyes

If this book were evidence, I, as a juror, would vote to acquit based on reasonable doubt. Monaghan and Cawthorne fail to make much of a connection (maybe no connection) between Walter’s secret diary and the gruesome Jack the Ripper murders. For example, Walter often gave his girls handkerchiefs; Handkerchiefs were found on the victims. As a hunter Walter owned a sharp knife and had a basic understanding of anatomy; the victims were mutilated by someone with a basic understanding of anatomy. The sight of blood aroused Walter; the crime scenes were bloody. The authors spend chapters and chapters emphasizing Walter’s unquenchable desire to deflower virgins. The Ripper’s victims were exclusively middle aged prostitutes.

Perhaps, somewhere in the eleven volume tome, more compelling evidence exists. The excerpts the authors chose to publish contain some of the most shocking and heinous sexual content many readers will ever encounter. Walter’s diary ranges in style from “letters to Penthouse” to detailed descriptions of criminal sexual deviance. That Walter is depraved is not in doubt; that Walter is Jack the Ripper is.

One thing the book does manage to convey is the shame of a social structure that allows such horrid crimes to occur. That so many are complicit in Walter’s licentiousness is hard to believe. That authorities ignore the plight of sexually enslaved women is disgraceful.

I love a good true crime where an author reveals the criminal through a series of facts tied together with a touch of innuendo and a few inferences. Unfortunately, in this book the innuendo is nothing more than lurid exposition and inferences giant leaps of faith.

Monaghan and Cawthorne fall far short of convincing me Walter is Jack the Ripper. For me, Jack the Ripper's Secret Confession was nothing more than a dirty book.
… (més)
 
Marcat
refice | May 18, 2010 |
If I read many more books like this, I will have to give up my prejudices against literary criticism. This is an interesting, readable and mainly jargon-free look at Jane Austen's portrayals of the social system of her time. I happened to read it at the same time that I was reading Claudia Johnson's Jane Austen, Women, Politics and the Novel and Margaret Kirkham's Jane Austen, Feminism and Fiction. I found that the three complemented each other very nicely both as contrasts and comparisons. Monaghan happily refrains from the bad academic habit of referring to his opinions in the third person.

My only cavil with the book is the Monaghan sometimes falls into the habit of attempting to organize the author's works as if they were a lecture series or necessary represented a changing trajectory of thought. Given Austen's maturity when her works were published in their final form, I doubt that she actually changed her mind very much. And I wonder how many authors actually plan their works as a series.

I suppose that we all chose the Jane Austen that we prefer, and I prefer the woman who's penetrating clarity and lack of sentimental delusion has startled a number of her readers. I further like to think that Austen had a complex view of the world and could see both the problems and advantages of say, a hereditary ruling class. I doubt that she had any simple view of almost anything: social class, children, marriage. I am one of those who think that she sympathized with Charlotte Lucas' reasons for accepting Mr. Collins' proposal, even if she deplored the situations that this lead to. If the representatives of the gentry, for example, were more sympathetically portrayed in one book that another, I believe that was not because she had changed her mind, but because she chose to view a different side of the issue.

The book contains an index, but no bibliography other than the notes. The notes themselves are nicely done, with the sections headed by the same running title that appears on the pages so that they are easy to match up. These notes continue additional factual information, so the reader will want to check them from time to time.
… (més)
½
 
Marcat
PuddinTame | Oct 6, 2007 |

Potser també t'agrada

Autors associats

Estadístiques

Obres
10
Membres
153
Popularitat
#136,480
Valoració
4.0
Ressenyes
2
ISBN
21
Llengües
1

Gràfics i taules