Michael Penman
Autor/a de The Kings & Queens of Scotland
Obres de Michael Penman
Obres associades
Thirteenth Century England XII: Proceedings of the Gregynog Conference, 2007 (2009) — Col·laborador — 1 exemplars
Etiquetat
Coneixement comú
Encara no hi ha coneixement comú d'aquest autor. Pots ajudar.
Membres
Ressenyes
Potser també t'agrada
Autors associats
Estadístiques
- Obres
- 5
- També de
- 1
- Membres
- 114
- Popularitat
- #171,985
- Valoració
- 3.3
- Ressenyes
- 1
- ISBN
- 11
Of course, given a particular anniversary this year this book is certainly a timely study. However, the form of idealised nationalism espoused perhaps by such as Alex Salmond MSP is not necessarily accommodated here. Robert Bruce is, in a sense, laid bare in all his heroism and glory- but also brutality and, occasionally, duplicity. That infamous incident with John Comyn in the church his role during the time of William Wallace are not avoided-and some traditional beliefs regarding these seriously questioned. The murder of Comyn, Penman suggests, may have been premeditated- the act of a man who required either the support or else the elimination of this prominent family to further his cause.
As for Wallace- it is claimed Wallace may well have favoured a Bruce claim- at least after the English victory at Falkirk.
Other myths and misconceptions are also refuted- I’ve known for a while that the notion that John Balliol was nothing more than a toadie of Edward I, forced upon the Scots by him, may not actually have been true- but this confirms it- and in fact Bruce himself was described as a ‘loyal servant’ of the English King at one point.
Yet such myth-busting is not the primary purpose of the work, and almost everything is covered, from land grants, marriages and alliances, to the re-organisation of the political landscape, diplomacy and international relations.
My only real complaint is that the detail of the work could leave the more general reader bogged down- it’s certainly taking me a long time to read, and I admit I have not yet finished it, but overall this is an excellent and useful account of the real Braveheart, who originally bore the epithet.
I received a free E-galley of this book from Netgalley for review, I was not required to write a positive one and all opinions expressed are my own.
… (més)