Imatge de l'autor

James Fitzjames Stephen (1829–1894)

Autor/a de Liberty, Equality, Fraternity

15+ obres 140 Membres 2 Ressenyes

Sobre l'autor

Crèdit de la imatge: G. F. Watts, d. 1904

Obres de James Fitzjames Stephen

Obres associades

Conservative Texts: An Anthology (1991) — Col·laborador — 8 exemplars

Etiquetat

Coneixement comú

Membres

Ressenyes

I discovered this book while reading something about Mill. It was a critique of Mill's On Liberty and it presents a number of arguments that are hard to fault, but also a number of arguments that, if spoken today, would require endless apologies and may even require one to step down as a politician. Nevertheless, Stephen was a lawyer (and later a notable judge) and at times he could be verbose, at other times insightful, at still others rather strange. Yet his critique of Mill leaves me with plenty of food for thought. He argues in the same way I have listened to conservatives argue against a Bill of Rights for Australia. There is a modicum of liberalism in the English sense of the word, and I might be presumptuous and say in a similar vein to Edmund Burke. When I read Mill, I felt like I was reading my own education in summary. When I read Stephen, I feel like I am getting an education. Some suggest that Liberty, Equality, Fraternity was James Fitzjames Stephen's masterpiece, and apparently Oxford is reproducing his works in several volumes. Stephen didn't disagree with utilitarianism nor liberalism, but he did disagree with the extremes of liberalism that Mill advocated, and especially against the emancipation of women as outlined in Mill's On the Subjection of Women. Stephen's arguments were deeply rooted in his conception of the evidence observed in nature, rather than an idealism as characterised by Mill. Yet Stephen's conclusion displays another form of idealism, and I couldn't help thinking that it was a rather weak way of summing up, rather like an undergraduate essay that lost its argument and tries to finish in an upbeat fashion. Yet there were many lessons to be gleaned from Stephen, and the Liberty Fund's inclusion of this work as an important contribution is well-founded, despite history's favouring Mill. I must admit that it took me a while to get through this, and the combination of wordy ideas and arguments, along with rather fine print, made this somewhat of an exercise in discipline rather than enlightenment. And I am all the wiser for doing so.… (més)
 
Marcat
madepercy | Hi ha 1 ressenya més | Nov 7, 2017 |
Stephen presents a conservative critique of John Stuart Mill's liberalism (very weak, I have to say, on the issue of women's rights).
 
Marcat
Fledgist | Hi ha 1 ressenya més | Jan 30, 2007 |

Potser també t'agrada

Autors associats

Estadístiques

Obres
15
També de
1
Membres
140
Popularitat
#146,473
Valoració
4.0
Ressenyes
2
ISBN
35
Llengües
1

Gràfics i taules