Foto de l'autor
14+ obres 497 Membres 12 Ressenyes

Sobre l'autor

Tim Whitmarsh is Reader in Greek Literature at the University of Exeter.

Inclou el nom: Timothy Whitmarsh

Obres de Tim Whitmarsh

Obres associades

A Companion to Ancient History (2009) — Col·laborador — 34 exemplars
The Oxford Handbook of Roman Studies (2010) — Col·laborador — 23 exemplars
The Oxford Handbook of Hellenic Studies (2009) — Col·laborador — 21 exemplars
The Oxford Handbook of the Second Sophistic (Oxford Handbooks) (2017) — Col·laborador — 12 exemplars
Greeks on Greekness: Viewing the Greek Past Under the Roman Empire (2006) — Col·laborador — 11 exemplars
African Athena: New Agendas (Classical Presences) (2011) — Col·laborador — 10 exemplars
Classical Pasts: The Classical Traditions of Greece and Rome (2005) — Col·laborador — 10 exemplars
Classics and the Uses of Reception (Classical Receptions) (2006) — Col·laborador — 9 exemplars
Severan Culture (2007) — Col·laborador — 9 exemplars
The Author's Voice in Classical and Late Antiquity (2013) — Col·laborador — 6 exemplars
Epistolary Narratives in Ancient Greek Literature (2013) — Col·laborador — 5 exemplars
Constructing Identities in Late Antiquity (1999) — Col·laborador — 5 exemplars
Paideia : the world of the second sophistic (2004) — Col·laborador — 5 exemplars
Readers and writers in the ancient novel (2009) — Col·laborador — 5 exemplars
Philostratus (2009) — Col·laborador — 4 exemplars
The Limits of Ancient Biography: Genre And Technique (2006) — Col·laborador — 4 exemplars
Textual Events: Performance and the Lyric in Early Greece (2018) — Col·laborador — 4 exemplars
Cultural Memories in the Roman Empire (2016) — Col·laborador — 3 exemplars
How to Do Things with History: New Approaches to Ancient Greece (2018) — Col·laborador — 2 exemplars
Classical antiquity (vol 29 no 2) — Col·laborador — 1 exemplars

Etiquetat

Coneixement comú

Nom normalitzat
Whitmarsh, Tim
Gènere
male
Nacionalitat
England
Organitzacions
Cambridge University

Membres

Ressenyes

What I found especially fascinating about this book was the fundamental point that he makes about peoples attitudes towards religion. The idea of a single unified faith community is a mirage ..both in the ancient world, in the medieval world and in the modern world: there has always been a spectrum of faith, belief and unbelief. As the author says: "This book represents a kind of archeology of religious skepticism". And he is open about the difficulty of relying on ancient texts (which may or may not represent accurately the common way of thinking). To my mind there is a over-reliance on the greek Dramatists and interpreting their works. However, even given some doubts about these sources, Whitmarsh manages to amass enough evidence to bolster his point that skepticism about the Gods and religion is not a new phenomenon. It has existed for thousands of years ...even in societies with no background in rational thought or debate.
There is an interesting discussion about the introduction of Diopeithe's decree in the 430's BC...Whitmarsh calls him a religious crackpot but his decree has massive and long lasting impact. Up until this decree the Athenians were pretty tolerant of varying beliefs about the gods. But following the decree ...to be a good citizen you not only had to do right but to think right too. In a way, this intolerance about "right-thinking" has echoed down through the ages with religious bigotry and intolerance and justified all sorts of terrible pogroms and religious wars....especially after the 300's AD when Christianity gained the ascendancy.
Atheists, after this decree, ran very real risks of being condemned for impiety and disbelief in the gods. and one hears the echoes of this intolerance with Galilio being shown the instruments of torture...to help change his beliefs; and Charles Darwin being reluctant to publish his findings for fear of offending his religious wife ....let alone the rest of the establishment of Victorian England.
There seem to be many in the ancient Greek world who not only didn't believe in the riotous goings-on at Mt Olympus but who rejected the concept of gods altogether. And I take my hat off to them. Diogenes, the cynic, who, whilst one man was marvelling at a series of temple inscriptions put up by survivors of sea storms, retorted that there would have been many more if the the non-survivors had also left dedications. Whitmarsh also makes the point that, as a rule, polytheism...the belief in many gods....was infinitely more hospitable to unbelievers than monotheism. Under Christianity, by contrast, there was no good way of being an atheist. Atheism was the categorical rejection of the very premise on which Christianity defined itself. (I think Augustine of Hippo bears a fair bit or responsibility for this intolerance which has continued don through the centuries ...and probably held back western civilisation from intellectual development for about a thousand years).
I would have liked to have seen more about atheism in other societies (for example, Egyptian, Persian, Chinese, Indian). But the author explains that although China for example had its atheists and other places also, the best historical writings and materials were available for Greece ....hence his concentration on this state. Rome is considered in the latter part of the book and, in general, was fairly tolerant of all sorts of religions and non-believers until the formal adoption of Christianity as the state religion...and with it....as mentioned above...came those wonderful attributes of intolerance, persecution, and execution for those who did not profess the "right-beliefs".
Generally, I found the book quite fascinating ..though also mildly depressing ...especially the persecution of non-believers that is a recurring theme. I give it four stars.
… (més)
 
Marcat
booktsunami | Hi ha 11 ressenyes més | Oct 18, 2021 |
This a really interesting book.
I would have rated it higher but I really struggle with these history books which are full of names and names and names and I can remember who anyone is and it all gets an it complicated. Sometimes the ideas got a bit lost in the detailing of events too, but I guess someone else might find this okay.

I didn't find it preachy or anything like that. Just a nice pile of thoughts and facts and commentary.
5 stars if I wasn't dyslexic and Greek memes weren't really hard to read and pretty confusing? I dunno, maybe.… (més)
 
Marcat
mjhunt | Hi ha 11 ressenyes més | Jan 22, 2021 |
Really enjoyed this book. I really enjoy anything based on history.
 
Marcat
AndreaWay | Hi ha 11 ressenyes més | Nov 15, 2020 |
Disappointing as most of the philosophers discussed didn't really seem to be atheists.
 
Marcat
Robertgreaves | Hi ha 11 ressenyes més | Jun 21, 2020 |

Llistes

Premis

Potser també t'agrada

Autors associats

John Wilkins Contributor, Editor
Simon Goldhill Contributor
Ewen Bowie Contributor
Jason Konig Contributor
Rebecca Flemming Contributor
Stephen Harrison Contributor
Susan A. Stephens Contributor
Lawrence Kim Contributor
Maud Gleason Contributor
Michael Reeve Contributor
John Morgan Contributor
Joan B. Burton Contributor
Massimo Fusillo Contributor
Shadi Bartsch Contributor
Andrew Laird Contributor
Froma Zeitlin Contributor
Catherine Connors Contributor
Helen Morales Contributor
James Romm Contributor
Gerald Sandy Contributor
Alice König Contributor
Daniela Manetti Contributor
Andrew M. Riggsby Contributor
James Warren Contributor
Thomas Habinek Contributor
Jacques Jouanna Contributor
Jason König Contributor
Victoria Rimell Contributor
Serafina Cuomo Contributor
Teun Tieleman Contributor
Vivian Nutton Contributor
John Henderson Contributor
G. E. R. Lloyd Contributor
R. J. Hankinson Contributor
Jennie Barbour Contributor
Greg Woolf Contributor
Clifford Ando Contributor
Stephanie Dalley Contributor
Emily Kneebone Contributor
Aldo Tagliabue Contributor
Onno van Nijf Contributor
Kim Ryholt Contributor
Ruth Webb Contributor
Ian Rutherford Contributor
Phiroze Vasunia Contributor
Daniel L. Selden Contributor
Stephen Mitchell Contributor
Ilaria Romeo Contributor
Johannes Haubold Contributor
Stephanie West Contributor
John Dillery Contributor
Josef Wiesehöfer Contributor
C. P. Jones Contributor
Pavlos Avlamis Contributor

Estadístiques

Obres
14
També de
30
Membres
497
Popularitat
#49,748
Valoració
3.8
Ressenyes
12
ISBN
53
Llengües
2

Gràfics i taules