| Títols | Ordre |
| My Most Excellent Year de Steve Kluger | Winner, 2009 |
| After Tupac and D Foster de Jacqueline Woodson | Finalist, 2009 |
| El llibre del cementiri de Neil Gaiman | Finalist, 2009 |
| Graceling de Kristin Cashore | Finalist, 2009 |
| Me, the Missing, and the Dead de Jenny Valentine | Finalist, 2009 |
| Fire de Kristin Cashore | Winner, 2010 |
| Marcelo In The Real World de Francisco Stork | Finalist, 2010 |
| The Monstrumologist de Rick Yancey | Finalist, 2010 |
| North Of Beautiful de Justina Chen Headley | Finalist, 2010 |
| The Sweetheart of Prosper County de Jill S. Alexander | Finalist, 2010 |
| The Last Summer Of The Death Warriors de Francisco Stork | Winner, 2011 |
| After Ever After de Jordan Sonnenblick | Finalist, 2011 |
| Sorta Like a Rock Star de Matthew Quick | Finalist, 2011 |
| I Will Save You de Matt de la Peña | Finalist, 2011 |
| Wolves, Boys and Other Things That Might Kill Me de Kristen Chandler | Finalist, 2011 |
| Shine de Lauren Myracle | Winner, 2012 |
| The Berlin Boxing Club de Robert Sharenow | Finalist, 2012 |
| Between Shades of Gray de Ruta Sepetys | Finalist, 2012 |
| Blood Red Road de Moira Young | Finalist, 2012 |
| Under the Mesquite de Guadalupe Garcia McCall | Finalist, 2012 |
| No està escrit a les estrelles de John Green | Winner, 2013 |
| Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe de Benjamin Alire Sáenz | Finalist, 2013 |
| Ask the Passengers de A. S. King | Finalist, 2013 |
| Endangered de Eliot Schrefer | Finalist, 2013 |
| Eleanor and Park de Rainbow Rowell | Winner, 2014 |
| Jumped In de Patrick Flores-Scott | Finalist, 2014 |
| The Milk of Birds de Sylvia Whitman | Finalist, 2014 |
| Openly Straight de Bill Konigsberg | Finalist, 2014 |
| Winger de Andrew Smith | Finalist, 2014 |
| Glory O'Brien's History of the Future de A. S. King | Winner, 2015 |
| Diamond Boy de Michael Williams | Finalist, 2015 |
| Gabi, a Girl in Pieces de Isabel Quintero | Finalist, 2015 |
| The Impossible Knife of Memory de Laurie Halse Anderson | Finalist, 2015 |
| Revolution de Deborah Wiles | Finalist, 2015 |
