| Títols | Ordre |
| Mouse Tales de Arnold Lobel | 1973 |
| Bear Mouse de Berniece Freschet | 1974 |
| Harlequin and the Gift of Many Colors de Remy Charlip | 1974 |
| She Come Bringing Me That Little Baby Girl de Eloise Greenfield | 1975 |
| The Maggie B. de Irene Haas | 1976 |
| Morris' Disappearing Bag de Rosemary Wells | 1976 |
| The Easter Egg Artists de Adrienne Adams | 1977 |
| Everyone Knows What a Dragon Looks Like de Jay Williams | 1977 |
| The Mysterious Tadpole de Steven Kellogg | 1978 |
| Felix in the attic de Larry Bograd | 1979 |
| The Garden of Abdul Gasazi de Chris Van Allsburg | 1980 |
| Gorky Rises de William Steig | 1981 |
| The Stories Julian Tells de Ann Cameron | 1982 |
| Mustard de Charlotte Graeber | 1983 |
| No One Is Going to Nashville de Mavis Jukes | 1984 |
| The Mysteries of Harris Burdick de Chris Van Allsburg | 1985 |
| Chloe and Maude de Sandra Boynton | 1986 |
| Doctor Change de Joanna Cole | 1987 |
| Heckedy Peg de Audrey Wood | 1988 |
| The Porcupine Mouse de Bonnie Pryor | 1989 |
| The Talking Eggs de Robert D. San Souci | 1990 |
| Charlie Anderson de Barbara Abercrombie | 1991 |
| El Bosc encantat : la primera història del màgic Arbre Remot de Enid Blyton | 1992 |
| The King's Equal de Katherine Paterson | 1993 |
| Three Sacks of Truth: A Story from France de Eric A. Kimmel | 1994 |
| Pink and Say de Patricia Polacco | 1995 |
| Wicked Jack de Connie Nordhielm Wooldridge | 1996 |
| Jojofu de Michael Waite | 1997 |
| Akiak: A Tale From the Iditarod de Robert J. Blake | 1998 |
| Raising Dragons de Jerdine Nolen | 1999 |
| Zak's Lunch de Margie Palatini | 1999 |
| A Dog Like Jack de Dyanne Disalvo-ryan | 2000 |
| Tasty Baby Belly Buttons de Judy Sierra | 2000 |
| Basho and the Fox de Tim J. Myers | Honor Book, 2001 |
| Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type de Doreen Cronin | Honor Book, 2001 |
| mammalabilia de Douglas Florian | Honor Book, 2001 |
| The Raft de Jim LaMarche | Winner, 2001 |
| And the Dish Ran Away with the Spoon de Janet Stevens | Honor Book, 2002 |
| A Fine, Fine School de Sharon Creech | Honor Book, 2002 |
| Milo's Hat Trick de Jon Agee | Honor Book, 2002 |
| The Three Pigs de David Wiesner | Winner, 2002 |
| Bubba and Beau, Best Friends de Kathi Appelt | Winner, 2003 |
| Epossumondas de Coleen Salley | Honor Book, 2003 |
| I Stink! de Kate McMullan | Honor Book, 2003 |
| The Dot de Peter H. Reynolds | Honor Book, 2004 |
| How I Became a Pirate de Melinda Long | Winner, 2004 |
| The Journey of Oliver K. Woodman de Darcy Pattison | Honor Book, 2004 |
| Tanuki's Gift de Tim J. Myers | Honor Book, 2004 |
| The Firekeeper's Son de Linda Sue Park | Honor Book, 2005 |
| Henry and the Kite Dragon de Bruce Edward Hall | Honor Book, 2005 |
| Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Tale de Mo Willems | Winner, 2005 |
| Wild About Books de Judy Sierra | Honor Book, 2005 |
| Precious and the Boo Hag de Patricia C. Mckissack | Honor Books, 2006 |
| Sammy: The Classroom Guinea Pig de Alix Berenzy | Winner, 2006 |
| Terrific de Jon Agee | Honor Books, 2006 |
| Willa and the Wind de Janice M. Del Negro | Honor Book, 2006 |
| Duck & Goose de Tad Hills | Honor Books, 2007 |
| El lleó de la biblioteca de Michelle Knudsen | Honor Books, 2007 |
| Once I Ate a Pie de Patricia MacLachlan | Winner, 2007 |
| Roasted Peanuts de Tim Egan | Honor Books, 2007 |
| The Chicken-Chasing Queen of Lamar County de Janice N. Harrington | Honor Books, 2008 |
| Martina the Beautiful Cockroach de Carmen Agra Deedy | Honor Books, 2008 |
| Nic Bishop Spiders de Nic Bishop | Honor Books, 2008 |
| The Wicked Big Toddlah de Kevin Hawkes | Winner, 2008 |
| Frogs de Nic Bishop | Honor Book, 2009 |
| The Ghost Catcher de Martha Hamilton | Honor Book, 2009 |
| Mail Harry to the Moon de Robie H. Harris | Winner, 2009 |
| What To Do About Alice?: How Alice Roosevelt Broke the Rules, Charmed the World, and Drove Her Father Teddy Crazy! de Barbara Kerley | Honor Book, 2009 |
| Billy Twitters and His Blue Whale Problem de Mac Barnett | Honor Book, 2010 |
| A Penguin Story de Antoinette Portis | Honor Book, 2010 |
| Robot Zot! de Jon Scieszka | Winner, 2010 |
| Sergio Saves the Game de Edel Rodriguez | Honor Book, 2010 |
| Children Make Terrible Pets de Peter Brown | Honor Book, 2011 |
| Dust Devil de Anne Isaacs | Honor Book, 2011 |
| How Rocket Learned to Read de Tad Hills | Winner, 2011 |
| A Pig Parade Is a Terrible Idea de Michael Ian Black | Honor Book, 2011 |
| All the Way to America: The Story of a Big Italian Family and a Little Shovel de Dan Yaccarino | Honor Book, 2012 |
| I Want My Hat Back de Jon Klassen | Honor Book, 2012 |
| What Animals Really Like de Fiona Robinson | Winner, 2012 |
| You Will Be My Friend! de Peter Brown | Honor Book, 2012 |
| Big Mean Mike de Michelle Knudsen | Winner, 2013 |
| The Duckling Gets a Cookie!? de Mo Willems | Honor Book, 2013 |
| Goldilocks and the Three Dinosaurs de Mo Willems | Honor Book, 2013 |
| This Is Not My Hat de Jon Klassen | Honor Book, 2013 |
| Are the Dinosaurs Dead, Dad? de Julie Middleton | Honor Book, 2014 |
| Chick-o-Saurus Rex de Lenore Jennewein | Honor Book, 2014 |
| The King of Little Things de Bil Lepp | Honor Book, 2014 |
| That Is Not a Good Idea! de Mo Willems | Winner, 2014 |
| Blizzard de John Rocco | Honor Book, 2015 |
| Elizabeth, Queen of the Seas de Lynne Cox | Honor Book, 2015 |
| Sam and Dave Dig a Hole de Mac Barnett | Winner, 2015 |
| Shh! We Have a Plan de Chris Haughton | Honor Book, 2015 |
| It's Only Stanley de Jon Agee | Winner, 2016 |
| Ragweed's Farm Dog Handbook de Anne Vittur Kennedy | Honor Book, 2016 |
| Red: A Crayon's Story de Michael Hall | Honor Book, 2016 |
| You Can Do It, Bert! de Ole Könnecke | Honor Book, 2016 |
| The Night Gardener de Terry Fan | Winner, 2017 |
| A Hungry Lion, or, A Dwindling Assortment of Animals de Lucy Ruth Cummins | Finalist, 2017 |
| Little Red and the Very Hungry Lion de Alex T. Smith | Finalist, 2017 |
| Quackers de Liz Wong | Finalist, 2017 |
