| Títols | Ordre |
| An American Sin de Frederick Su | Shortlist, 2002 |
| Empire Settings de David Schmahmann | 2002 |
| The Ghost of Bridgetown de Debra Spark | Shortlist, 2002 |
| Jobs & Other Preoccupations: Stories de Daniel Coshnear | Shortlist, 2002 |
| Milk de Emily Hammond | Shortlist, 2002 |
| Opposable Thumbs de Suzanne Hudson | Shortlist, 2002 |
| Alberta Clipper de John Salter | Shortlist, 2003 |
| The Kind of Things Saints Do (Iowa Short Fiction Award) de Laura Valeri | 2003 |
| Miracle at St. Anna de James McBride | Shortlist, 2003 |
| No Place, Louisiana de Martin Pousson | Shortlist, 2003 |
| Whispers in dust and bone de Andrew Geyer | Shortlist, 2003 |
| Acts of Love on Indigo Road: New and Selected Stories de Jonis Agee | Shortlist, 2004 |
| Good Faith de Jane Smiley | Shortlist, 2004 |
| A Memory of War de Frederick Busch | Shortlist, 2004 |
| Monkey Hunting de Cristina Garcia | Shortlist, 2004 |
| Speed-walk : and other stories de Suzanne Greenberg | Shortlist, 2004 |
| La Vella escola de Tobias Wolff | 2004 |
| Bring Your Legs With You (Pitt Drue Heinz Lit Prize) de Darrell Spencer | Shortlist, 2005 |
| Curled in the Bed of Love: Stories de Catherine Brady | Shortlist, 2005 |
| Inheritance de Lan Samantha Chang | Shortlist, 2005 |
| The Moon in Its Flight de Gilbert Sorrentino | Shortlist, 2005 |
| Sabbath Creek de Judson Mitcham | Shortlist, 2005 |
| Somewhere Geese are Flying: New and Selected Stories de Gary Gildner | Shortlist, 2005 |
| The Turk and My Mother: A Novel de Mary Helen Stefaniak | 2005 |
| What You've Been Missing: Isfa (Iowa Short Fiction Award) de Janet Desaulniers | Shortlist, 2005 |
| Giovanna's 86 Circles: And Other Stories (Library of American Fiction) de Paola Corso | Shortlist, 2006 |
| Hope and Other Dangerous Pursuits de Laila Lalami | Shortlist, 2006 |
| Love and Ghost Letters de Chantel Acevedo | Shortlist, 2006 |
| More Like Not Running Away: A Novel (Mary Mccarthy Prize in Short Fiction) de Paul Shepherd | Shortlist, 2006 |
| Mother of Sorrows de Richard McCann | Shortlist, 2006 |
| Waiting for Elvis de Toni Graham | 2006 |
| The Last Flight of Jose Luis Balboa de Gonzalo Barr | Shortlist, 2007 |
| The Mover of Bones (Flyover Fiction) de Robert Vivian | Shortlist, 2007 |
| Newsworld (Pitt Drue Heinz Lit Prize) de Todd James Pierce | Shortlist, 2007 |
| The Quick-Change Artist: Stories de Cary Holladay | Shortlist, 2007 |
| Tehano de Allen Wier | Shortlist, 2007 |
| Tin God de Terese Svoboda | Shortlist, 2007 |
| Tolstoy Lied: A Love Story de Rachel Kadish | 2007 |
| Triangle de Katharine Weber | Shortlist, 2007 |
| Because a Fire Was in My Head (Flyover Fiction) de Lynn Stegner | Shortlist, 2008 |
| The Inheritance of Exile: Stories from South Philly de Susan Muaddi Darraj | Shortlist, 2008 |
| Openwork de Adria Bernardi | Shortlist, 2008 |
| The Pale of Settlement de Margot Singer | Shortlist, 2008 |
| Paradise road de Kirk Nesset | Shortlist, 2008 |
| The River Wife de Jonis Agee | 2008 |
| Tourist Season: Stories de Enid Shomer | Shortlist, 2008 |
| I Am Not Sidney Poitier de Percival Everett | Shortlist, 2010 |
| Feeding Strays de Stefanie Freele | Shortlist, 2010 |
| God's Dogs: A Novel in Stories de Mitch Wieland | Shortlist, 2010 |
| How to Leave Hialeah (Iowa Short Fiction Award) de Jennine Capó Crucet | 2010 |
| Mrs. Somebody Somebody de Tracy Winn | Shortlist, 2010 |
| The New Valley: Novellas de Josh Weil | Shortlist, 2010 |
| All Is Forgotten, Nothing Is Lost de Lan Samantha Chang | Shortlist, 2011 |
| How to Be an American Housewife de Margaret Dilloway | Shortlist, 2011 |
| Llibertat de Jonathan Franzen | 2011 |
| My Bright Midnight (Yellow Shoe Fiction) de Josh Russell | Shortlist, 2011 |
| The Queen of Palmyra de Minrose Gwin | Shortlist, 2011 |
| The Three Weissmanns of Westport de Cathleen Schine | Shortlist, 2011 |
| Blood Clay de Valerie Nieman | Shortlist, 2012 |
| The Grief of Others de Leah Hager Cohen | Shortlist, 2012 |
| Outside the Bones de Lyn Di Iorio | Shortlist, 2012 |
| Sweet Hope (Prose Series) de Mary Bucci Bush | Shortlist, 2012 |
| The Uncoupling de Meg Wolitzer | 2012 |
| All That I Am de Anna Funder | Shortlist, 2013 |
| Breaking and Entering: A Novel de Eileen Pollack | Shortlist, 2013 |
| The Cutting Season: A Novel de Attica Locke | Shortlist, 2013 |
| Flight Behavior de Barbara Kingsolver | Shortlist, 2013 |
| Little Sinners, and Other Stories (Prairie Schooner Book Prize in Fiction) de Karen Brown | 2013 |
| The Mirage de Matt Ruff | Shortlist, 2013 |
| Flimsy Little Plastic Miracles de Jr. Ron Currie | Shortlist, 2014 |
| A Guide to Being Born: Stories de Ramona Ausubel | Shortlist, 2014 |
| Housebound de Elizabeth Gentry | Shortlist, 2014 |
| Lotería de Mario Alberto Zambrano | Shortlist, 2014 |
| The Miniature Wife: and Other Stories de Manuel Gonzales | 2014 |
| My Life as a Silent Movie: A Novel (Break Away Books) de Jesse Lee Kercheval | Shortlist, 2014 |
| The Virgins de Pamela Erens | Shortlist, 2014 |
| The Hollow Ground de Natalie S. Harnett | 2015 |
| Lila de Marilynne Robinson | Shortlist, 2015 |
| My So-Called Ruined Life (Tate McCoy Series) de Melanie Bishop | Shortlist, 2015 |
| Radiance of Tomorrow de Ishmael Beah | Shortlist, 2015 |
| We are Not Ourselves de Matthew Thomas | Shortlist, 2015 |
| The Art of Crash Landing de Melissa DeCarlo | Shortlist, 2016 |
| Nonprofit de Matt Burriesci | Shortlist, 2016 |
| Shriver de Chris Belden | Shortlist, 2016 |
| The Sorrow Proper de Lindsey Drager | 2016 |
| Black Deutschland de Darryl Pinckney | Shortlist, 2017 |
| Desert Boys: Fiction de Chris McCormick | Shortlist, 2017 |
| Dog Years (Pitt Drue Heinz Lit Prize) de Melissa Yancy | Shortlist, 2017 |
| The Grand Tour de Adam O'Fallon Price | Shortlist, 2017 |
| The Loss of All Lost Things de Amina Gautier | Shortlist, 2017 |
| Some Possible Solutions de Helen Phillips | 2017 |
| The Universe Playing Strings: A Novel de R. M. Kinder | Shortlist, 2017 |
| The Animators de Kayla Rae Whitaker | Shortlist, 2018 |
| Five-Carat Soul de James McBride | Shortlist, 2018 |
| The Goat Fish and the Lover's Knot (Made in Michigan Writers Series) de Jack Driscoll | Shortlist, 2018 |
| The King Is Always Above the People: Stories de Daniel Alarcón | Shortlist, 2018 |
| The Place of Stones: A Novel de Ali Hosseini | Shortlist, 2018 |
| Roads, Where There Are No Roads: A Novel de Angela Jackson | 2018 |
| The Affliction de C. Dale Young | Shortlist, 2019 |
| Call Me Zebra de Azareen van der Vliet Oloomi | 2019 |
| Friday Black de Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah | Shortlist, 2019 |
| The Hunger de Alma Katsu | Shortlist, 2019 |
| She Would Be King de Wayétu Moore | Shortlist, 2019 |
| Trinity de Louisa Hall | Shortlist, 2019 |
