| Títols | Ordre |
| Sukey and the Mermaid de Robert D. San Souci | 1994-1995 |
| Soap! Soap! Don't Forget the Soap!: An Appalachian Folktale de Tom Birdseye | 1995-1996 |
| My Rotten Redheaded Older Brother de Patricia Polacco | 1996-1997 |
| Heart of a Tiger de Marsha Diane Arnold | 1997-1998 |
| Duke the Dairy Delight Dog de Lisa Campbell Ernst | 1998-1999 |
| Verdi de Janell Cannon | 1999-2000 |
| Raising Dragons de Jerdine Nolen | 2000-2001 |
| Hooway for Wodney Wat de Helen Lester | 2001-2002 |
| Go Home!: The True Story of James the Cat de Libby Phillips Meggs | 2002-2003 |
| The Frog Principal de Stephanie Calmenson | 2003-2004 |
| Epossumondas de Coleen Salley | 2004-2005 |
| Bad Boys de Margie Palatini | 2005-2006 |
| Arrowhawk de Lola M. Schaefer | 2006-2007 |
| Magnus at the Fire de Jennifer Armstrong | 2007-2008 |
| Hero Cat de Eileen Spinelli | 2008-2009 |
| Some Dog! de Mary Casanova | 2009-2010 |
| Two Bobbies: A True Story of Hurricane Katrina, Friendship, and Survival de Kirby Larson | 1st Place, 2010-2011 |
| For the Love of Autumn de Patricia Polacco | 2nd Place, 2010-2011 |
| Titanicat (True Stories) de Marty Crisp | 3rd Place, 2010-2011 |
| Nubs: The True Story of a Mutt, a Marine & a Miracle de Brian Dennis | 1st Place, 2011-2012 |
| Dewey: There's a Cat in the Library! de Vicki Myron | 2nd Place, 2011-2012 |
| Twist of Fate: The Miracle Colt and His Friends de Chris Stuckenschneider | 3rd Place, 2011-2012 |
| The Blue House Dog de Deborah Blumenthal | 1st Place, 2012-2013 |
| Memoirs of a Goldfish de Devin Scillian | 2nd Place, 2012-2013 |
| Pierre the Penguin: A True Story de Jean Marzollo | 3rd Place, 2012-2013 |
| Painter and Ugly de Robert J. Blake | 1st Place, 2013-2014 |
| A Book for Black-Eyed Susan de Judy Young | 2nd Place, 2013-2014 |
| Charlie the Ranch Dog de Ree Drummond | 3rd Place, 2013-2014 |
| Jangles: A Big Fish Story de David Shannon | 1st Place, 2014-2015 |
| Creepy Carrots! de Aaron Reynolds | 2nd Place, 2014-2015 |
| Helen's Big World: The Life of Helen Keller de Doreen Rappaport | 3rd Place, 2014-2015 |
