| Títols | Ordre |
| Death on Demand de Carolyn G. Hart | First Mystery Novel, 1988 |
| Murder Unrenovated de P. M. Carlson | Novel, 1988 |
| Every Crooked Nanny de Kathy Hogan Trocheck | First Novel, 1993 |
| A Share in Death de Deborah Crombie | First Novel, 1993 |
| To Live & Die in Dixie de Kathy Hogan Trocheck | Novel, 1994 |
| 'G' Is for Grafton : The World of Kinsey Millhone de Natalie Hevener Kaufman | Nonfiction, 1998 |
| The Ax de Donald E. Westlake | Novel, 1998 |
| Charm City de Laura Lippman | First Novel, 1998 |
| El Club Dumas de Arturo Pérez-Reverte | Novel, 1998 |
| Guilty Parties: A Mystery Lover's Companion de Ian Ousby | Nonfiction, 1998 |
| Hocus de Jan Burke | Novel, 1998 |
| Killing Floor de Lee Child | Best First Novel, 1998 |
| The Napoleon of Crime: The Life and Times of Adam Worth, the Real Moriarty de Ben Macintyre | Nonfiction, 1998 |
| Off the Face of the Earth de Aljean Harmetz | First Novel, 1998 |
| The Salaryman's Wife de Sujata Massey | Best First Novel, 1998 |
| Trunk Music de Michael Connelly | Novel, 1998 |
| Blind Descent de Nevada Barr | Novel, 1999 |
| Blue de Abigail Padgett | Novel, 1999 |
| Butchers Hill de Laura Lippman | Novel, 1999 |
| Dark city : the lost world of film noir de Eddie Muller | Critical/Biographical, 1999 |
| The Doctor Digs a Grave de Robin Hathaway | First Novel, 1999 |
| Home Fires de Margaret Maron | Novel, 1999 |
| Mystery Reader's Walking Guide, Washington, D.C. de Alzina Stone Dale | Critical/Biographical, 1999 |
| Silk Stalkings: When Women Write of Murder de Victoria Nichols | Critical/Biographical, 1999 |
| Speaking of Murder: Interviews With the Masters of Mystery and Suspense, Vol. 1 de Ed Gorman | Critical/Biographical, 1999 |
| Tiger's Palette (Caroline Canfield Mysteries) de Jacqueline Fiedler | First Novel, 1999 |
| In a Dry Season de Peter Robinson | Novel, 2000 |
| L. A. Requiem de Robert Crais | Novel, 2000 |
| Murder in the Marais de Cara Black | First Novel, 2000 |
| Murder with Peacocks de Donna Andrews | First Novel, 2000 |
| Revenge of the Gypsy Queen de Kris Neri | First Novel, 2000 |
| River of Darkness de Rennie Airth | Novel, 2000 |
| A Taste of Murder: Diabolically Delicious Recipes from Contemporary Mystery Writers de Jo Grossman | Nonfiction, 2000 |
| Teller of Tales: The Life of Arthur Conan Doyle de Daniel Stashower | Nonfiction, 2000 |
| 100 Favorite Mysteries of the Century de Jim Huang | Nonfiction, 2001 |
| The Bottoms de Joe R. Lansdale | Novel, 2001 |
| Crow in Stolen Colors de Marcia Simpson | First Novel, 2001 |
| Death Dances to a Reggae Beat de Kate Borden | First Novel, 2001 |
| The Doctor and the Detective: A Biography of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle de Martin Booth | Nonfiction, 2001 |
| Guns and Roses: A Modern Mystery Set in Colonial Willamsburg de Taffy Cannon | Novel, 2001 |
| Three Dirty Women and the Garden of Death de Julie Wray Herman | First Novel, 2001 |
| The Whole Truth de Nancy Pickard | Novel, 2001 |
| Women of Mystery: The Lives and Works of Notable Women Crime Novelists de Martha Hailey DuBose | Nonfiction, 2001 |
| Blindsighted de Karin Slaughter | First Novel, 2002 |
| The Dead House de Linda Fairstein | Novel, 2002 |
| The history of mystery de Max Allan Collins | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2002 |
| The Jasmine Trade de Denise Hamilton | First Novel, 2002 |
| My Name's Friday : The Unauthorized but True Story of Dragnet and the Films of Jack Webb de Michael J. Hayde | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2002 |
| Mystic River de Dennis Lehane | Novel, 2002 |
| Perhaps She'll Die de M. K. Preston | First Novel, 2002 |
| Silent Joe de T. Jefferson Parker | Novel, 2002 |
| Tell No One de Harlan Coben | Novel, 2002 |
| Who Was That Lady? Craig Rice: The Queen of Screwball Mystery de Jeffrey Marks | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2002 |
| The art of noir : the posters and graphics from the classic era of film noir de Eddie Muller | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2003 |
| The Blue Edge of Midnight de Jonathon King | First Novel, 2003 |
| City of Bones de Michael Connelly | Novel, 2003 |
| The Distance de Eddie Muller | First Novel, 2003 |
| Intent to Sell de Jeffrey Marks | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2003 |
| Jolie Blon's Bounce de James Lee Burke | Novel, 2003 |
| The Mammoth Book of Historical Crime Fiction de Mike Ashley | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2003 |
| Nine de Jan Burke | Novel, 2003 |
| Savannah Blues de Mary Kay Andrews | Novel, 2003 |
| A Valley to Die For de Radine Trees Nehring | First Novel, 2003 |
| Beautiful Shadow: A Life of Patricia Highsmith de Andrew Wilson | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2004 |
| The Bridge of Sighs de Olen Steinhauer | First Novel, 2004 |
| Death of a Nationalist (Soho Crime) de Rebecca Pawel | First Novel, 2004 |
| The Delicate Storm de Giles Blunt | Novel, 2004 |
| Done for a Dime de David Corbett | Novel, 2004 |
| For the Love of Mike de Rhys Bowen | Novel, 2004 |
| The Guards de Ken Bruen | Novel, 2004 |
| Mystery Women: An Encyclopedia of Leading Women Characters in Mystery Fiction Volume III (1990-1999) Part 1: A-L de Colleen Barnett | Bio/Critical Mystery, 2004 |
| The Night of the Dance de James Hime | First Novel, 2004 |
| California Girl de T. Jefferson Parker | Novel, 2005 |
| Cold Case de Robin Burcell | Novel, 2005 |
| Darkly Dreaming Dexter de Jeff Lindsay | Novel, 2005 |
| Famous American Crimes and Trials: Volume 5, 1981-2000 de Frankie Y. Bailey | Nonfiction, 2005 |
| High Country Fall de Margaret Maron | Novel, 2005 |
| Just the Facts: True Tales of Cops & Criminals de Jim Doherty | Nonfiction, 2005 |
| Latin American Mystery Writers: An A-to-Z Guide de Darrell B. Lockhart | Nonfiction, 2005 |
| Misdemeanor Man: A Novel de Dylan Schaffer | First Novel, 2005 |
| The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes: The Short Stories, Volume 1 de Arthur Conan Doyle | Nonfiction, 2005 |
| Playing with Fire de Peter Robinson | Novel, 2005 |
| Summer of the Big Bachi de Naomi Hirahara | First Novel, 2005 |
| Uncommon Grounds de Sandra Balzo | First Novel, 2005 |
| Whiskey Sour de J.A. Konrath | First Novel, 2005 |
| All Shook Up de Mike Harrison | First Novel, 2006 |
| The Baby Game de Randall Hicks | First Novel, 2006 |
| Behind the Mystery: Top Mystery Writers Interviewed by Stuart Kaminsky and Photographed by Laurie Roberts de Stuart Kaminsky | Non-Fiction, 2006 |
| In Like Flynn de Rhys Bowen | Historical Mystery, 2006 |
| Night's Child de Maureen Jennings | Historical Mystery, 2006 |
| One Shot de Lee Child | Novel, 2006 |
| The Power of the Dog de Don Winslow | Novel, 2006 |
| Solomon vs. Lord de Paul Levine | Novel, 2006 |
| Spectres in the Smoke de Tony Broadbent | Historical Mystery, 2006 |
| Spook: Science Tackles the Afterlife de Mary Roach | Non-Fiction, 2006 |
| Strange Affair de Peter Robinson | Novel, 2006 |
| Tracks To Murder (True Crime Series (Kent, Ohio)) de Jonathan Goodman | Non-Fiction, 2006 |
| Vanish de Tess Gerritsen | Novel, 2006 |
| The War of the Worlds Murder de Max Allan Collins | Historical Mystery, 2006 |
| 47 Rules of Highly Effective Bank Robbers de Troy Cook | First Novel, 2007 |
| All Mortal Flesh de Julia Spencer-Fleming | Novel, 2007 |
| L'arbre dels Geníssers de Jason Goodwin | Novel, 2007 |
| The Beautiful Cigar Girl: Mary Rogers, Edgar Allan Poe, and the Invention of Murder de Daniel Stashower | Non-Fiction, 2007 |
| The Bee's Kiss de Barbara Cleverly | Historical Mystery, 2007 |
| Consigned to Death de Jane K. Cleland | First Novel, 2007 |
| Dark Assassin de Anne Perry | Historical Mystery, 2007 |
| The Dead Hour de Denise Mina | Novel, 2007 |
| Don't Murder Your Mystery de Chris Roerden | Non-Fiction, 2007 |
| El secret de Christine Falls de Benjamin Black | Novel, 2007 |
| A Field of Darkness de Cornelia Read | First Novel, 2007 |
| The King of Lies de John Hart | First Novel, 2007 |
| The Lightning Rule: A Novel de Brett Ellen Block | Historical Mystery, 2007 |
| Messenger of Truth de Jacqueline Winspear | Historical Mystery, 2007 |
| Piece of My Heart de Peter Robinson | Novel, 2007 |
| Arthur Conan Doyle: Life in Letters de Arthur Conan Doyle | Non-Fiction, 2008 |
| Blood of Paradise de David Corbett | Novel, 2008 |
| Chester Gould: A Daughter's Biography of the Creator of Dick Tracy de Jean Gould O'connell | Non-Fiction, 2008 |
| The Collaborator of Bethlehem de Matt Beynon Rees | First Novel, 2008 |
| Consequences of Sin de Clare Langley-Hawthorne | Historical Mystery, 2008 |
| Els Turmentats de John Connolly | Novel, 2008 |
| The Gravedigger's Daughter de Joyce Carol Oates | Historical Mystery, 2008 |
| Heart-Shaped Box de Joe Hill | First Novel, 2008 |
| Her Royal Spyness de Rhys Bowen | Historical Mystery, 2008 |
| Police Procedure & Investigation: A Guide for Writers (Howdunit) de Lee Lofland | Non-Fiction, 2008 |
| The Rough Guide to Crime Fiction de Barry Forshaw | Non-Fiction, 2008 |
| La serp de pedra de Jason Goodwin | Historical Mystery, 2008 |
| Soul Patch de Reed Farrel Coleman | Novel, 2008 |
| The Spellman Files de Lisa Lutz | First Novel, 2008 |
| Stealing the Dragon de Tim Maleeny | First Novel, 2008 |
| Water Like a Stone de Deborah Crombie | Novel, 2008 |
| The Blood Detective de Dan Waddell | First Novel, 2009 |
| Calumet City: A Novel de Charlie Newton | First Novel, 2009 |
| A Carrion Death de Michael Stanley | First Novel, 2009 |
| Company of Liars de Karen Maitland | Historical Mystery, 2009 |
| The Cruelest Month de Louise Penny | Novel, 2009 |
| Curse of the Spellmans de Lisa Lutz | Novel, 2009 |
| Death of a Cozy Writer de G. M. Malliet | First Mystery, 2009 |
| Edgar Allan Poe: An Illustrated Companion to His Tell-Tale Stories de Harry Lee Poe | Nonfiction, 2009 |
| The Fault Tree de Louise Ure | Novel, 2009 |
| Finding Nouf de Zoe Ferraris | First Novel, 2009 |
| Hard-Boiled Sentimentality: The Secret History of American Crime Fiction de Leonard Cassuto | Nonfiction, 2009 |
| L'home del llac de Arnaldur Indridason | Novel, 2009 |
| How to Write Killer Historical Mysteries: The Art and Adventure of Sleuthing Through the Past de Kathy Lynn Emerson | Nonfiction, 2009 |
| An Innocent Client de Scott Pratt | First Novel, 2009 |
| Nox Dormienda (A Long Night for Sleeping) de Kelli Stanley | Historical Mystery, 2009 |
| The Price of Blood de Declan Hughes | Novel, 2009 |
| Scene of the Crime: The Importance of Place in Crime and Mystery Fiction de David Geherin | Nonfiction, 2009 |
| Stealing Trinity de Ward Larsen | Historical Mystery, 2009 |
| The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher: A Shocking Murder and the Undoing of a Great Victorian Detective de Kate Summerscale | Nonfiction, 2009 |
| Trigger City de Sean Chercover | Novel, 2009 |
| Veil of Lies de Jeri Westerson | Historical Mystery, 2009 |
| The Whiskey Rebels de David Liss | Historical Mystery, 2009 |
| Among the Mad de Jacqueline Winspear | Historical Mystery, 2010 |
| A Bad Day for Sorry de Sophie Littlefield | First Novel, 2010 |
| A Beautiful Place to Die de Malla Nunn | First Novel, 2010 |
| The Brutal Telling de Louise Penny | Best Novel, 2010 |
| Bury Me Deep de Megan Abbott | Best Novel, 2010 |
| Dame Agatha's Shorts de Elena Santangelo | Nonfiction, 2010 |
| A Duty to the Dead de Charles Todd | Historical Mystery, 2010 |
| In the Shadow of Gotham de Stefanie Pintoff | Historical Mystery, 2010 |
| L.A. Noir: The Struggle for the Soul of America's Most Seductive City de John Buntin | Nonfiction, 2010 |
| The Lineup: The World's Greatest Crime Writers Tell the Inside Story of Their Greatest Detectives de Otto Penzler | Nonfiction, 2010 |
| Necessary as Blood de Deborah Crombie | Best Novel, 2010 |
| Nèmesi de Jo Nesbo | Best Novel, 2010 |
| Provenance: how a con man and a forger rewrote the history of modern art de Laney Salisbury | Nonfiction, 2010 |
| Rogue Males de Craig McDonald | Nonfiction, 2010 |
| Running from the Devil: A Novel de Jamie Freveletti | First Novel, 2010 |
| Serpent in the Thorns de Jeri Westerson | Historical Mystery, 2010 |
| The Shanghai Moon de S. J. Rozan | Best Novel, 2010 |
| The Twelve de Stuart Neville | First Novel, 2010 |
| Charlie Chan: The Untold Story of the Honorable Detective and His Rendezvous with American History de Yunte Huang | Nonfiction, 2011 |
| The Damage Done de Hilary Davidson | First Novel, 2011 |
| Faithful Place de Tana French | Novel, 2011 |
| The Fifth Servant de Kenneth Wishnia | Historical Mystery, 2011 |
| Following the Detectives: Real Locations in Crime Fiction de Maxim Jakubowski | Nonfiction, 2011 |
| Full Mortality de Sasscer Hill | First Novel, 2011 |
| The Glass Rainbow de James Lee Burke | Novel, 2011 |
| A Marked Man de Barbara Hamilton | Historical Mystery, 2011 |
| The Poacher's Son de Paul Doiron | First Novel, 2011 |
| The Poisoner's Handbook: Murder and the Birth of Forensic Medicine in Jazz Age New York de Deborah Blum | Nonfiction, 2011 |
| The Queen of Patpong de Timothy Hallinan | Novel, 2011 |
| The Red Door de Charles Todd | Historical Mystery, 2011 |
| Rupture de Simon Lelic | First Novel, 2011 |
| The Scent of Rain and Lightning de Nancy Pickard | Novel, 2011 |
| Thirteen Hours de Deon Meyer | Novel, 2011 |
| The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet de David Mitchell | Historical Mystery, 2011 |
| Thrillers: 100 Must-Reads de David Morrell | Nonfiction, 2011 |
| 1222 de Anne Holt | Novel, 2012 |
| Agatha Christie: Murder in the Making de John Curran | Nonfiction, 2012 |
| Books, Crooks and Counselors: How to Write Accurately About Criminal Law and Courtroom Procedure de Leslie Budewitz | Nonfiction, 2012 |
| Desconfia de tothom de S. J. Watson | First Novel, 2012 |
| Hell and Gone de Duane Swierczynski | Novel, 2012 |
| The House of Silk de Anthony Horowitz | Novel, 2012 |
| The Informationist de Taylor Stevens | First Novel, 2012 |
| Learning to Swim de Sara J. Henry | First Novel, 2012 |
| A Lesson in Secrets de Jacqueline Winspear | Historical Mystery, 2012 |
| Mercury's Rise de Ann Parker | Historical Mystery, 2012 |
| Narrows Gate de Jim Fusilli | Historical Mystery, 2012 |
| Naughty in Nice de Rhys Bowen | Historical Mystery, 2012 |
| Nazareth Child (Del Shannon, Book 1) de Darrell James | First Novel, 2012 |
| The Ridge de Michael Koryta | Novel, 2012 |
| The Savage City: Race, Murder, and a Generation on the Edge de T. J. English | Nonfiction, 2012 |
| A Trick of the Light de Louise Penny | Novel, 2012 |
| Troubled Bones de Jeri Westerson | Historical Mystery, 2012 |
| Turn of Mind de Alice LaPlante | First Novel, 2012 |
| Wilkie Collins, Vera Caspary and the Evolution of the Casebook Novel de A. B. Emrys | Nonfiction, 2012 |
| The Art Forger de B. A. Shapiro | Novel, 2013 |
| The Blackhouse de Peter May | Novel, 2013 |
| A City of Broken Glass de Rebecca Cantrell | Historical Mystery, 2013 |
| The Confession de Charles Todd | Historical Mystery, 2013 |
| Elegy for Eddie de Jacqueline Winspear | Historical Mystery, 2013 |
| The Expats de Chris Pavone | First Novel, 2013 |
| In Pursuit of Spenser: Mystery Writers on Robert B. Parker and the Creation of an American Hero de Otto Penzler | Nonfiction, 2013 |
| The Last Policeman de Ben H. Winters | Novel, 2013 |
| Lowcountry Boil de Susan M. Boyer | First Novel, 2013 |
| Midnight in Peking de Paul French | Nonfiction, 2013 |
| Mr. Churchill's Secretary de Susan Elia MacNeal | First Novel, 2013 |
| Perduda de Gillian Flynn | Novel, 2013 |
| Princess Elizabeth's Spy de Susan Elia MacNeal | Historical Mystery, 2013 |
| The Twenty-Year Death (Hard Case Crime) de Ariel S. Winter | Novel, 2013 |
| Cover of Snow de Jenny Milchman | First Novel, 2014 |
| Dandy Gilver and a Bothersome Number of Corpses de Catriona McPherson | Historical Mystery, 2014 |
| Dead Lions de Mick Herron | Novel, 2014 |
| How the Light Gets In de Louise Penny | Novel, 2014 |
| The Lady and Her Monsters: A Tale of Dissections, Real-Life Dr. Frankensteins, and the Creation of Mary Shelley's Masterpiece de Roseanne Montillo | Nonfiction, 2014 |
| A Murder at Rosamund's Gate de Susanna Calkins | Historical Mystery, 2014 |
| Norwegian by Night de Derek B. Miller | First Novel, 2014 |
| The Other Woman de Hank Phillippi Ryan | First Novel, 2014 |
| Rage Against the Dying de Becky Masterman | First Novel, 2014 |
| Ratlines de Stuart Neville | Historical Mystery, 2014 |
| Sandrine's Case de Thomas H. Cook | Novel, 2014 |
| Saving Lincoln de Robert Kresge | Historical Mystery, 2014 |
| Standing in Another Man's Grave de Ian Rankin | Novel, 2014 |
| The Wicked Girls de Alex Marwood | Novel, 2014 |
| Yesterday's Echo de Matt Coyle | First Novel, 2014 |
| 400 Things Cops Know: Street-Smart Lessons from a Veteran Patrolman de Adam Plantinga | Nonfiction, 2015 |
| The Black Hour de Lori Rader-Day | First Novel, 2015 |
| Blessed Are the Dead de Kristi Belcamino | First Novel, 2015 |
| Dandy Gilver and a Deadly Measure of Brimstone de Catriona McPherson | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| The Day She Died de Catriona McPherson | Novel, 2015 |
| Dear Daughter de Elizabeth Little | First Novel, 2015 |
| Dry Bones in the Valley de Tom Bouman | First Novel, 2015 |
| The Figure of the Detective: A Literary History and Analysis de Charles Brownson | Nonfiction, 2015 |
| Hunting Shadows de Charles Todd | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| Invisible City de Julia Dahl | First Novel, 2015 |
| The Killer Next Door de Alex Marwood | Novel, 2015 |
| The Last Death of Jack Harbin de Terry Shames | Novel, 2015 |
| The Long Way Home de Louise Penny | Novel, 2015 |
| The Missing Place de Sophie Littlefield | Novel, 2015 |
| An Officer and a Spy de Robert Harris | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| Poe-Land: The Hallowed Haunts of Edgar Allan Poe de J. W. Ocker | Nonfiction, 2015 |
| Present Darkness de Malla Nunn | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| Queen of Hearts de Rhys Bowen | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| Someone Else's Skin de Sarah Hilary | First Novel, 2015 |
| Things Half in Shadow de Alan Finn | Historical Mystery, 2015 |
| Writes of Passage: Adventures on the Writer's Journey de Hank Phillippi Ryan | Nonfiction, 2015 |
| The Cartel de Don Winslow | Mystery, 2016 |
| The Child Garden de Catriona McPherson | Mystery, 2016 |
| Concrete Angel de Patricia Abbott | First Novel, 2016 |
| Dreaming Spies de Laurie R. King | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2016 |
| Forensics: What Bugs, Burns, Prints, DNA, and More Tell Us About Crime de Val McDermid | Critical/Biographical, 2016 |
| A Gilded Grave de Shelley Freydont | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2016 |
| The Hot Countries de Timothy Hallinan | Mystery, 2016 |
| A is for Arsenic: the Poisons of Agatha Christie de Kathryn Harkup | Critical/Biographical, 2016 |
| The Killing Kind de Chris Holm | First Mystery, 2016 |
| The Lady from Zagreb de Philip Kerr | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2016 |
| Life or Death de Michael Robotham | Mystery, 2016 |
| Little Black Lies: A Novel de Sharon Bolton | Mystery, 2016 |
| The Lost Detective: Becoming Dashiell Hammett de Nathan Ward | Critical/Biographical, 2016 |
| Meanwhile There Are Letters: The Correspondence of Eudora Welty and Ross Macdonald de Suzanne Marrs | Critical/Biographical, 2016 |
| On The Road with Del & Louise: A Novel in Stories de Art Taylor | First Mystery, 2016 |
| The Secret Life of Anna Blanc de Jennifer Kincheloe | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2016 |
| Tom & Lucky (and George & Cokey Flo) de C. Joseph Greaves | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2016 |
| The Unquiet Dead de Ausma Zehanat Khan | 2016 |
| Where All Light Tends to Go de David Joy | First Mystery, 2016 |
| Dodgers de Bill Beverly | First Novel, 2017 |
| Before the Fall de Noah Hawley | Novel, 2017 |
| Dark Fissures de Matt Coyle | Novel, 2017 |
| Real Tigers de Mick Herron | Novel, 2017 |
| Wilde Lake de Laura Lippman | Novel, 2017 |
| You Will Know Me de Megan Abbott | Novel, 2017 |
| Design for Dying de Renee Patrick | First Novel, 2017 |
| Under the Harrow de Flynn Berry | First Novel, 2017 |
| The Widow de Fiona Barton | First Novel, 2017 |
| Autumn at the Automat de Lawrence Block | Short Story, 2017 |
| Dandy Gilver and the Reek of Red Herrings de Catriona McPherson | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2017 |
| A Death Along the River Fleet de Susanna Calkins | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2017 |
| Delivering the Truth de Edith Maxwell | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2017 |
| Jane Steele de Lyndsay Faye | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2017 |
| What Gold Buys de Ann Parker | Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award, 2017 |
| Mastering Suspense, Structure, and Plot: How to Write Gripping Stories That Keep Readers on the Edge of Their Seats de Jane K. Cleland | Nonfiction, 2017 |
| Shirley Jackson: A Rather Haunted Life de Ruth Franklin | Nonfiction, 2017 |
| Something in the Blood: The Untold Story of Bram Stoker, the Man Who Wrote Dracula de David J. Skal | Nonfiction, 2017 |
| The Wicked Boy: The Mystery of a Victorian Child Murderer de Kate Summerscale | Nonfiction, 2017 |
| Arthur and Sherlock: Conan Doyle and the Creation of Holmes de Michael Sims | Nonfiction, 2018 |
| Cast the First Stone: An Ellie Stone Mystery (Ellie Stone Mysteries) de James W. Ziskin | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2018 |
| Chester B. Himes: A Biography de Lawrence P. Jackson | Nonfiction, 2018 |
| Dangerous to Know de Renee Patrick | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2018 |
| The Devouring de James R. Benn | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2018 |
| From Holmes to Sherlock: The Story of the Men and Women Who Created an Icon de Mattias Boström | Nonfiction, 2018 |
| Lady Killers: Deadly Women Throughout History de Tori Telfer | Nonfiction, 2018 |
| The Man from the Train: The Solving of a Century-Old Serial Killer Mystery de Bill James | Nonfiction, 2018 |
| Racing the Devil de Charles Todd | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2018 |
| A Rising Man de Abir Mukherjee | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2018 |
| Bluebird, Bluebird de Attica Locke | Novel, 2018 |
| The Force de Don Winslow | Novel, 2018 |
| Glass Houses de Louise Penny | Novel, 2018 |
| The Marsh King's Daughter de Karen Dionne | Novel, 2018 |
| The Old Man de Thomas Perry | Novel, 2018 |
| The Dry de Jane Harper | First Novel, 2018 |
| Hollywood Homicide de Kellye Garrett | First Novel, 2018 |
| The Last Place You Look de Kristen Lepionka | First Novel, 2018 |
| Lost Luggage de Wendall Thomas | First Novel, 2018 |
| She Rides Shotgun: A Novel de Jordan Harper | First Novel, 2018 |
| Agatha Christie: An English Mystery de Laura Thompson | Nonfiction, 2019 |
| The Chalk Man de C. J. Tudor | First Novel, 2019 |
| City of Ink de Elsa Hart | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2019 |
| Classic American Crime Fiction of the 1920s de Leslie S. Klinger | Nonfiction, 2019 |
| Conan Doyle for the Defense: The True Story of a Sensational British Murder, a Quest for Justice, and the World's Most Famous Detective Writer de Margalit Fox | Nonfiction, 2019 |
| A Dying Note de Ann Parker | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2019 |
| A Forgotten Place de Charles Todd | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2019 |
| Hiroshima Boy de Naomi Hirahara | Novel, 2019 |
| I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer de Michelle McNamara | Nonfiction, 2019 |
| If I Die Tonight de Alison Gaylin | Novel, 2019 |
| Island of the Mad de Laurie R. King | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2019 |
| Jar of Hearts de Jennifer Hillier | Novel, 2019 |
| A Lady's Guide to Etiquette and Murder de Dianne Freeman | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2019 |
| The Lost Man de Jane Harper | Novel, 2019 |
| The Metaphysical Mysteries of G.K. Chesterton: A Critical Study of the Father Brown Stories and Other Detective Fiction de Laird R. Blackwell | Nonfiction, 2019 |
| My Sister, the Serial Killer de Oyinkan Braithwaite | First Novel, 2019 |
| Something in the Water de Catherine Steadman | First Novel, 2019 |
| Under My Skin de Lisa Unger | Novel, 2019 |
| Where the Crawdads Sing de Delia Owens | First Novel, 2019 |
| American Spy de Lauren Wilkinson | Macavity Award Nominee, 2020 |
| Beyond the Thirty-Nine Steps: A Life of John Buchan de Ursula Buchan | Best Mystery Nonfiction/Critical, 2020 |
| Call Me Evie de JP Pomare | Best First Mystery, 2020 |
| Charity's Burden de Edith Maxwell | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2020 |
| Frederic Dannay, Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine and the Art of the Detective Short Story de Laird R. Blackwell | Best Mystery Nonfiction/Critical, 2020 |
| Indecent Advances: A Hidden History of True Crime and Prejudice Before Stonewall de James Polchin | Best Mystery Nonfiction/Critical, 2020 |
| Lady in the Lake de Laura Lippman | Best Mystery Novel, 2020 |
| A Lady's Guide to Gossip and Murder de Dianne Freeman | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2020 |
| Miracle Creek de Angie Kim | Best First Mystery, 2020 |
| Murder Knocks Twice de Susanna Calkins | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2020 |
| The Murder List de Hank Phillippi Ryan | Best Mystery Novel, 2020 |
| The Mutual Admiration Society: How Dorothy L. Sayers and her Oxford Circle Remade the World for Women de Mo Moulton | Best Mystery Nonfiction/Critical, 2020 |
| My Lovely Wife de Samantha Downing | Best First Mystery, 2020 |
| The Ninja Daughter de Tori Eldridge | Best First Mystery, 2020 |
| Norco '80: The True Story of the Most Spectacular Bank Robbery in American History de Peter Houlahan | Best Mystery Nonfiction/Critical, 2020 |
| The Pearl Dagger (An Art Deco Mystery Book 3) de L. A. Chandlar | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2020 |
| Sarah Jane de James Sallis | Best Mystery Novel, 2020 |
| The Satapur Moonstone de Sujata Massey | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2020 |
| This Tender Land de William Kent Krueger | Best Mystery Novel, 2020 |
| Your House Will Pay de Steph Cha | Macavity Award Nominee, 2020 |
| All the Devils Are Here de Louise Penny | Best Mystery Novel, 2021 |
| Blind Vigil de Matt Coyle | Best Mystery Novel, 2021 |
| The Cabinets of Barnaby Mayne de Elsa Hart | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2021 |
| Darling Rose Gold de Stephanie Wrobel | Best First Mystery, 2021 |
| Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line de Deepa Anappara | Best First Mystery, 2021 |
| The Double Lives of Clementine Lakefield de Caroline Cooney | Best Mystery Novel, 2021 |
| Howdunit: A Masterclass in Crime Writing by Members of the Detection Club de Martin Edwards | Best Mystery Critical/Biographical, 2021 |
| Ian Rankin: A Companion to the Mystery Fiction (McFarland Companions to Mystery Fiction, 10) de Erin E. Macdonald | Best Mystery Critical/Biographical, 2021 |
| The Last Mrs Summers de Rhys Bowen | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2021 |
| The Mimosa Tree Mystery de Ovidia Yu | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2021 |
| Mortal Music de Ann Parker | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2021 |
| Sometimes You Have to Lie: The Life and Times of Louise Fitzhugh, Renegade Author of Harriet the Spy de Leslie Brody | Best Mystery Critical/Biographical, 2021 |
| Southern Cross Crime de Craig Sisterson | Best Mystery Critical/Biographical, 2021 |
| These Women de Ivy Pochoda | Best Mystery Novel, 2021 |
| The Thursday Murder Club de Richard Osman | 2021 |
| The Turning Tide de Catriona McPherson | Sue Feder Memorial Award for Best Historical Mystery, 2021 |
| When She Was Good de Michael Robotham | Best Mystery Novel, 2021 |
