| Títols | Ordre |
| Diary of a Worm de Doreen Cronin | Winner, 2005 |
| Buster de Denise Fleming | Honors, 2005 |
| How I Became a Pirate de Melinda Long | Honors, 2005 |
| Jungle Drums de Graeme Base | Winner, 2006 |
| Mighty Jackie: The Strike-Out Queen de Marissa Moss | Honors, 2006 |
| I Wanna Iguana de Karen Kaufman Orloff | Honors, 2006 |
| The Great Fuzz Frenzy de Janet Stevens | Winner, 2007 |
| Badly Drawn Dog de Emma Dodson | Honors, 2007 |
| I See a Kookaburra!: Discovering Animal Habitats Around the World de Steve Jenkins | Honors, 2007 |
| Aliens Are Coming!: The True Account Of The 1938 War Of The Worlds Radio Broadcast de Meghan McCarthy | Winner, 2008 |
| Bats at the Beach de Brian Lies | Honors, 2008 |
| Duck & Goose de Tad Hills | Honors, 2008 |
| My Dog is As Smelly As Dirty Socks: And Other Funny Family Portraits de Hanoch Piven | Winner, 2009 |
| Bob and Otto de Robert O. Bruel | Honors, 2009 |
| The End de David LaRochelle | Honors, 2009 |
| The Wolves Are Back de Jean Craighead George | Winner, 2010 |
| The Little Bit Scary People de Emily Jenkins | Honors, 2010 |
| Turtle's Penguin Day de Valeri Gorbachev | Honors, 2010 |
| The Circus Ship de Chris Van Dusen | Winner, 2011 |
| Lousy Rotten Stinkin' Grapes de Margie Palatini | Honors, 2011 |
| Tsunami! de Kimiko Kajikawa | Honors, 2011 |
| Interrupting Chicken de David Ezra Stein | Winner, 2012 |
| En Calvin no sap volar : la història d'un ocell lletraferit de Jennifer Berne | Honors, 2012 |
| Pierre the Penguin: A True Story de Jean Marzollo | Honors, 2012 |
| Won Ton: A Cat Tale Told in Haiku de Lee Wardlaw | Winner, 2013 |
| Marshall Armstrong is New to Our School de David Mackintosh | Honors, 2013 |
| Monkey: A Trickster Tale from India de Gerald McDermott | Honors, 2013 |
| Jangles: A Big Fish Story de David Shannon | Winner, 2014 |
| Mrs. Harkness and the Panda de Alicia Potter | Honors, 2014 |
| Too Tall Houses de Gianna Marino | Honors, 2014 |
| Carnivores de Aaron Reynolds | Winner, 2015 |
| Exclamation Mark de Amy Krouse Rosenthal | Honors, 2015 |
| Miracle Mud: Lena Blackburne and the Secret Mud That Changed Baseball de David A. Kelly | Honors, 2015 |
