| Títols | Ordre |
| Bud, Not Buddy de Christopher Paul Curtis | Winner, 1999 |
| Come On, Rain de Karen Hesse | Honor, 1999 |
| The Hatseller And The Monkeys de Baba Wague Diakite | Honor, 1999 |
| Red-Eyed Tree Frog de Joy Cowley | Honor, 1999 |
| Because of Winn-Dixie de Kate DiCamillo | Winner, 2000 |
| Olivia de Ian Falconer | Honor, 2000 |
| One Lighthouse, One Moon de Anita Lobel | Honor, 2000 |
| So You Want to Be President? de Judith St. George | Honor, 2000 |
| Grandma's Records de Eric Velasquez | Honor, 2001 |
| Love That Dog de Sharon Creech | Winner, 2001 |
| The Other Side de Jacqueline Woodson | Honor, 2001 |
| A Poke in the I: A Collection of Concrete Poems de Paul B. Janeczko | Honor, 2001 |
| Ruby Holler de Sharon Creech | Honor, 2002 |
| The Same Stuff as Stars de Katherine Paterson | Honor, 2002 |
| When Marian Sang: The True Recital of Marian Anderson de Pam Muñoz Ryan | Honor, 2002 |
| When My Name Was Keoko de Linda Sue Park | Winner, 2002 |
| G is for Goat de Patricia Polacco | Honor, 2003 |
| Old Cricket de Lisa Wheeler | Winner, 2003 |
| Sahara Special de Esme Raji Codell | Honor, 2003 |
| The Tale of Despereaux: Being the Story of a Mouse, a Princess, Some Soup and a Spool of Thread de Kate DiCamillo | Honor, 2003 |
| Ida B: . . . and Her Plans to Maximize Fun, Avoid Disaster, and (Possibly) Save the World de Katherine Hannigan | Winner, 2004 |
| Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Tale de Mo Willems | Honor, 2004 |
| The Young Man And The Sea de Rodman Philbrick | Honor, 2004 |
| I Ain't Gonna Paint No More! de Karen Beaumont | Winner, 2005 |
| The Liberation of Gabriel King de K. L. Going | Honor, 2005 |
| Willow Run de Patricia Reilly Giff | Honor, 2005 |
| Clementine de Sara Pennypacker | Honor, 2006 |
| Counting on Grace de Elizabeth Winthrop | Honor, 2006 |
| The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane de Kate DiCamillo | Honor, 2006 |
| Rules de Cynthia Lord | Winner, 2006 |
| A Crooked Kind of Perfect de Linda Urban | Winner, 2007 |
| La invenció de l'Hugo Cabret de Brian Selznick | Honor, 2007 |
| No Talking de Andrew Clements | Honor, 2007 |
| Theodosia and the Serpents of Chaos de R. L. LaFevers | Honor, 2007 |
| The Wednesday Wars de Gary D. Schmidt | Honor, 2007 |
| Alvin Ho: Allergic to Girls, School, and Other Scary Things de Lenore Look | Honor, 2008 |
| Diamond Willow de Helen Frost | Winner, 2008 |
| The Gollywhopper Games de Jody Feldman | Honor, 2008 |
| Knucklehead: Tall Tales and Almost True Stories of Growing up Scieszka de Jon Scieszka | Honor, 2008 |
| Ten Little Fingers and Ten Little Toes de Mem Fox | Honor, 2008 |
| The Mostly True Adventures Of Homer P. Figg de Rodman Philbrick | Winner, 2009-2010 |
| Birds de Kevin Henkes | Honor, 2009-2010 |
| Operation Yes de Sara Lewis Holmes | Honor, 2009-2010 |
| The Story of Snow: The Science of Winter's Wonder de Mark Cassino | Honor, 2009-2010 |
| Where the Mountain Meets the Moon de Grace Lin | Honor, 2009-2010 |
| Because of Mr. Terupt de Rob Buyea | Honor, 2011 |
| Candy Bomber: The Story of the Berlin Airlift's "Chocolate Pilot" de Michael O. Tunnell | Honor, 2011 |
| City Dog, Country Frog de Mo Willems | Winner, 2011 |
| Fora de mi de Sharon M. Draper | Honor, 2011 |
| GUYKU: A Year of Haiku for Boys de Bob Raczka | Honor, 2011 |
| What the Ladybird Heard de Julia Donaldson | Honor, 2011 |
| Balloons over Broadway: The True Story of the Puppeteer of Macy's Parade (Bank Street College of Education Flora Stieglitz Straus Award (Awards)) de Melissa Sweet | Honor, 2012 |
| Breaking Stalin's Nose de Eugene Yelchin | Winner, 2012 |
| The One and Only Ivan de Katherine Applegate | Honor, 2012 |
| Wonder de R. J. Palacio | Honor, 2012 |
| Wonderstruck de Brian Selznick | Honor, 2012 |
| The Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls de Claire Legrand | Honor, 2013 |
| Dogs on Duty: Soldiers' Best Friends on the Battlefield and Beyond de Dorothy Hinshaw Patent | Winner, 2013 |
| Liar & Spy de Rebecca Stead | Honor, 2013 |
| Nic Bishop Snakes de Nic Bishop | Honor, 2013 |
| Deep in the Sahara de Kelly Cunnane | Honor, 2014 |
| Flora and the Flamingo de Molly Idle | Honor, 2014 |
| Mr. Tiger Goes Wild de Peter Brown | Winner, 2014 |
| Rufus Goes to School de Kim T. Griswell | Honor, 2014 |
| Xander's Panda Party de Linda Sue Park | Honor, 2014 |
