"Is Donald Trump a Civilized Man?" I asked Anton Chekov.

ConversesAll Writers Considered

Afegeix-te a LibraryThing per participar.

"Is Donald Trump a Civilized Man?" I asked Anton Chekov.

Aquest tema està marcat com "inactiu": L'últim missatge és de fa més de 90 dies. Podeu revifar-lo enviant una resposta.

1Limelite
Editat: set. 23, 2016, 10:24pm

And he said. . .

Cultured people must, in my opinion, satisfy the following conditions:

1. They respect human personality, and therefore they are always kind, gentle, polite, and ready to give in to others. They do not make a row because of a hammer or a lost piece of india-rubber; if they live with anyone they do not regard it as a favour and, going away, they do not say “nobody can live with you.” They forgive noise and cold and dried-up meat and witticisms and the presence of strangers in their homes.
2. They have sympathy not for beggars and cats alone. Their heart aches for what the eye does not see…. They sit up at night in order to help P…., to pay for brothers at the University, and to buy clothes for their mother.
3. They respect the property of others, and therefor pay their debts.
4. They are sincere, and dread lying like fire. They don’t lie even in small things. A lie is insulting to the listener and puts him in a lower position in the eyes of the speaker. They do not pose, they behave in the street as they do at home, they do not show off before their humbler comrades. They are not given to babbling and forcing their uninvited confidences on others. Out of respect for other people’s ears they more often keep silent than talk.
5. They do not disparage themselves to rouse compassion. They do not play on the strings of other people’s hearts so that they may sigh and make much of them. ,” or “I have become second-rate,” because all this is striving after cheap effect, is vulgar, stale, false….
6. They have no shallow vanity. They do not care for such false diamonds as knowing celebrities, shaking hands with the drunken P., {Translator’s Note: Probably Palmin, a minor poet.} listening to the raptures of a stray spectator in a picture show, being renowned in the taverns…. If they do a pennyworth they do not strut about as though they had done a hundred roubles’ worth, and do not brag of having the entry where others are not admitted…. The truly talented always keep in obscurity among the crowd, as far as possible from advertisement.…. Even Krylov has said that an empty barrel echoes more loudly than a full one.
7. If they have a talent they respect it. They sacrifice to it rest, women, wine, vanity…. They are proud of their talent…. Besides, they are fastidious.
8. They develop the aesthetic feeling in themselves. They cannot go to sleep in their clothes, see cracks full of bugs on the walls, breathe bad air, walk on a floor that has been spat upon, cook their meals over an oil stove. They seek as far as possible to restrain and ennoble the sexual instinct…. What they want in a woman is not a bed-fellow… They do not ask for the cleverness which shows itself in continual lying. They want especially, if they are artists, freshness, elegance, humanity, the capacity for motherhood…. They do not swill vodka at all hours of the day and night, do not sniff at cupboards, for they are not pigs and know they are not. They drink only when they are free, on occasion…. For they want mens sana in corpore sano {a healthy mind in a healthy body}.


"Thank you," I said. "You've made it very clear, Mr. Chekov. Donald Trump fails the test."

"Ahhh," he replied, "the Barbarian is always at the gate."

2elenchus
set. 24, 2016, 8:35am

Are there instructive passages on how to deal with the Barbarian? Perhaps it is time I read some of the stories on my TBR pile.

3Limelite
Editat: set. 24, 2016, 2:35pm

>2 elenchus:
The only method I'm aware of is to marry the Barbarian's daughter. Ewww!

I read an interesting book about this subject ("civilized" vs. "barbarian" people) that surprised me because it was better than I expected. Who, exactly, is really civilized is debatable. If it's not in your TBR pile, look for Silk Road, by Colin Falconer.

4Meredy
set. 24, 2016, 4:13pm

>3 Limelite: I enjoyed that book a lot. Read it in tandem with Valerie Hansen's scholarly The Silk Road and found, as always with such pairings, that they illuminated each other.

>1 Limelite: Indeed, the quintessential boor. Can't you see Queen Elizabeth sticking her head in the oven sooner than receive him at Buckingham Palace?

(And how easily I can imagine him saying "I have better furniture than this. My paintings are bigger than those.")

All the better to recognize barbarism when we see it.

5Cecrow
set. 26, 2016, 7:27am

It reads to me as though being a politician and a cultured person are tautologically exclusive. Granted it may apply especially to Trump, which goes to show he's more like an extreme example of a politician than someone who can override the system.

6Limelite
set. 27, 2016, 10:01pm

>4 Meredy:

LoL! After last night's debate that I'm sure QEII has been briefed on, I imagine there's now a red velvet cushion in front of a porcelain Delft oven for her to kneel on.