I wasn't the one to give this book to my baby grandson. But I wish I had been. The whole family loves this book: though it's conceivable that my grandson, at 5 months, may not appreciate the wholesome moral, that Crime Does Not Pay. Little fish steals the trilby belonging to big fish, and is perfectly sure he's got away with it. But he hasn't.

The illustrations complement the spare text. Look at the eyes of the big fish as he goes in pursuit of the little one. Laugh at the devious crab. Enjoy hunting through the reedbed for little fish.

This is a dark tale for a toddler. But I'm sure toddlers can cope.

Addendum, Dec. 2016: My grandson is now nearly 18 months old. We're all still hugely enjoying this book. So is he. ( )

I find this a very surprising Caldecott winner. The illustrations are lovely, very interesting and expressive. The story is strange though, why did the small fish steal the hat? What happens in the end, is he eaten? It seems a bit heavy for a children's book, and did not feel award worthy to me at all. ( )

5/5 ( )

Independent Reading Level: Preschool - 3rd Grade
Awards: Caldecott Medal (2013)

Jon Klassen presents a story with a complex ethical message about stealing. A small, unreliable fish narrates this story about how easy it was to steal the hat of a larger fish. The small fish boasts that the larger fish won't even wake up or notice that the hat is missing. But when the larger fish wakes up he does notice the missing hat causing the little fish to hide. The small fish is convinced the theft will go unnoticed. What will happen when the big fish takes action? ( )