excellent - Ruthie
fair - Katrina

This story is a coming of age novel about best friends Joel and Tony, who are best friends despite their different characteristics. It's an unforgettable story of peer pressure, honesty, guilt, regret, and the consequences that result from choices made. It is a story that reminds the reader that we are not alone in our suffering or struggles. ( )

Two boys set out for a long summer bike ride to some bluffs in the local state park, but Tony, the daredevil of the two, pushes Joel (who has been hesitant about the whole expedition from the start) to do something Joel knows is too dangerous: go for a swim in the river. Joel has promised his dad not to do anything he shouldn't, but Tony is persistent, and both boys pay for it in different ways, in the end. A short but powerful book that skillfully captures childhood friendships, peer pressures, and survivor's guilt. ( )

This book is great for literacy circles. It is a fiction book that makes you want to keep reading. ( )

On My Honor is a story about two boys Joel and Tony who decide to go to swim in the creek on a hot summer day. This normal summer day turns into one of the worst days of Joel's life. As his friend Tony who is constantly daring and challenging him to engage in risky behaviors disappears under the water. This book teaches students about respect and honestly with your family and friends but most importantly with yourself. ( )