Clica una miniatura per anar a Google Books.
S'està carregant… China in Ten Words (2010)de Yu Hua
Cap S'està carregant…
Apunta't a LibraryThing per saber si aquest llibre et pot agradar. No hi ha cap discussió a Converses sobre aquesta obra. Yu Hua takes 10 words which define the thinking of the modern Chinese people and takes us on a trip down memory lane - both his and his country's - defining and illustrating the words. Born in 1960, he ended up in school during most of the Cultural revolution and that shaped how he looks at language and words - their meaning changes and gets redefined but the old meanings never get forgotten. If you are expecting a history of modern China, look somewhere else. Yes, there is a lot of history in this book but it is a mix between personal recollections and personal observations of other stories than a proper story. The 10 essays (some of them more connected with each others that others) all start with the Cultural revolution and end up today (well, the today of 2010) and they all draw comparisons between the two eras that should be as different from each other as humanly possible. And yet, they are not. Because they are old part of the same. Some of the anecdotes being told were amusing (how to find a book to read in China when all books were banned and burned for example or where to find a cold place in a hot day), some made me rethink what I thought I knew about China (hitting a teacher was something I did not expect - especially in a society known for teacher' veneration). They all add up to a picture of a China that Yu Hua wants us to see. And that is as important to remember as is what we do actually see in the text. The book was banned in China (it is still not published there - the Chinese version is published in Taiwan; parts of it were reworked into a different book in 2015 and that was published). And that is not surprising - the China of this book is ugly and not what the leadership would like to present to the world. One thing that he mentions as part of his exploration of the words usage in Chinese but which is also highlighted by his choice of words is how the same words may hint at different things depending on who uses them. The last two "copycat" and "bamboozle", especially the last one, have very different connotations in English that some of the ones that apparently are there in Chinese (but also some similar ones). And for others, the meaning comes from history. That made me thing about my struggle with English occasionally (less and less as time passes and I live in an English speaking country now) - when I see a word or an expression from the prism of my Bulgarian viewpoint. And just as a last note, at the very end of the essay about Reading , I found one of the best definitions of literature I had seen lately: "If literature truly possesses a mysterious power, I think perhaps it is precisely this: that one can read a book by a writer of a different time, a different country, a different race, a different language, and a different culture and there encounter a sensation that is one's very own." He was talking about the German poet Heine - but I suspect that any reader has their own example of this. Not a perfect book by any means (and the constant bringing up of the Cultural revolution as a parallel of the current times did get a bit annoying at parts and made me wonder if it was designed to provoke) but an entertaining one nevertheless. A fascinating and dryly amusing set of essays, Yu Hua's China in Ten Words mixes the author's boyhood experiences of the Cultural Revolution with reflections on the mores of contemporary China. Tonally, each essay wobbles a bit internally—from wry raconteur to irritated polemicist and back again—but each provides a marvellous glimpse at the complexities and contradictions of life in modern China. Great little book, which I do think sums up China very nicely. The author is one of my favorites, and here in this book particularly he reminds me a lot of Mark Twain, although he reports being compared to Ernest Hemingway--fair enough. Anyways, the book is largely based on the author's biographical sketches but his anecdotes are charming and informative. He circles back to the Cultural Revolution that took place in China from 1966 until 1976, and I can't knock him at all for coming back to it repeatedly, because it greatly shaped the lives of Chinese and it uncannily betrays many idiosyncrasies and contradictions, if you will, of life in China, even today. Anecdotes from a Great Writer Yu Hua is one of the world's great writers of fiction. His books are full of depth, character, and insight. Unfortunately, "China in Ten Words" falls flat. The book includes ten essays about each word (such as reading, bamboozle, leader). Unfortunately, there is little room for a cultural evaluation of the words. Instead, the reader is presented with a list of anecdotes and thoughts that have some coherence with the given word of each chapter. For example, in the essay titled "Copycat," we simply learn that Yu Hua's previous books have been pirated and that Chinese companies engage in such practices. There is little nuance and little beyond a definition and a few examples. The translation reads well and the book is very quick. Unfortunately, it doesn't provide much insight into what China is like today, or in the past.
Llistes notables
Uses a framework of ten common phrases in the Chinese vernacular to offer insight into China's modern economic gaps, cultural transformations, and ubiquitous practices of deception. No s'han trobat descripcions de biblioteca. |
Debats actualsCapCobertes populars
Google Books — S'està carregant… GèneresClassificació Decimal de Dewey (DDC)985.1History and Geography South America Peru Northwest PeruLCC (Clas. Bibl. Congrés EUA)ValoracióMitjana:
Ets tu?Fes-te Autor del LibraryThing. |
Jü Hua mindezt személyes példák tömkelegével igyekszik illusztrálni, érdekesen, gyakran kifejezetten szórakoztatóan – bár ami azt illeti, nekem néha kicsit sok is volt az a példa. Mondjuk minden ötödiket becseréltem volna egy mélyebb elemzésre, és akkor rendben vagyunk. De azért ajánlom ezt a könyvet – annyit hallunk a kínai gazdasági csodáról, meg hogy micsoda követendő példa az „ázsiai út”, érdemes egy picit mögé nézni, nincs-e a szép illúziók mögött egy csúnya kis gonosz manó.
* Amely vadkapitalizmus magát továbbra is kommunizmusnak hazudja, pedig abból csak az állami túlszabályozás gyakorlatát őrizte meg, ám a vagyoni egyenlőségnek még az illúzióját is feladta.
** ”A forradalom nem díszebéd, nem egy írásmű megalkotása, nem egy kép megrajzolása, és nem hímzés; nem lehet olyan kifinomult, olyan könnyed, illedelmes, olyan gyengéd, kedves, udvarias, tartózkodó és nagylelkű. A forradalom lázadás, erőszakos cselekedet, amellyel az egyik osztály megdönti a másikat.” ("Vizsgálati jelentés a hunani parasztmozgalomról" (1927. március), Válogatott Művek I. k.) ( )