When I first picked up October Light I thought it was going to be this old-timey story about two elderly siblings, living in seething resentment of one another in a farmhouse somewhere in Vermont. Admittedly, the book jacket didn't give me much to go on.
So, the plot: James Page is angry at the world. So angry he can't stand his sister Sally's droning television and ends up silencing it with a shotgun blast. The shooting of the television sets in motion a series of events - James locks Sally in a room (but seemingly not her own room because she finds a trashy novel which doesn't belong to her). She becomes absorbed in said trashy novel; literally can't put it down and refuses to come out of the bedroom, even when her niece convinces James to free her. James doesn't care either way. In truth, he is not without deep rooted grief, a grief that has hardened to him. One son committed suicide and another died in an accident. James's sister, widowed and a polar opposite, does nothing to comfort him. The epic sibling battle lasts for the entire book and escalates to a catastrophic ending.
I have to admit, I didn't enjoy the frame novel technique. Sally's trashy novel seemed to be the story Gardner really wanted to write. There is no explanation of how this trashy novel came to be in her room until the end. In truth, the story came alive for me in the last fifty pages. ( )

full of fine writing, exuberant writing, mock fiction, deep fiction, and wonderful characters.

The siblings James and Sally are sharing the Bennington, Vermont family house in their old age. James inherited the farm, and Sally came to live with him when her money ran out after being widowed. It hasn't gone especially well. James is hard, determined to reject all modernity, and Sally is equally stubborn. When James turns his shotgun on her television, the war is on.

Locked (and self-locked) in her upstairs bedroom, Sally spends her defiant isolation reading a tattered pulp fiction novel that she would never have touched in other circumstances. We read along with her, as she escapes from the domestic war into San Francisco drug running, sexual license and derring-do, constantly interrupted by missing pages. It is true escapist reading, but it's not only the room she is escaping from.

The Vermont story expands to include James's daughter's family, his friends at the local bar, the local minister and guests, other people in the town, even some Bennington girls. And it expands into memories of childhood, courtship, married life, relatives lost one way or another, and the work and beauty of the land. Ultimately, it is not only the bedroom door that is unlocked. ( )

Here, in one of Garnder's first novels, domestic warfare between 2 spirited, overl opinionated senior citizens -- brother and sister -- brings chaos to their community of friends and family. Gardner's story says much about that vital tension at the heart of American line -- the conflict between tradition and progressivism -- and about the difficult business of pushing beyond this conflict to find a place where one cant stand, secure and untroubled beneath the haunted, holy light that comes with an autumn in the Land of the Free! - Adam

The book within a book didn't work for me. I really don't know what Gardner was trying to do here. It's supposed to be pulp fiction, but it wasn't a typical thriller in style. I like straight narratives, so I think his "jazzing around" was not my speed. The main novel is filled with long, long passages of inner thoughts, and not a lot of action. It comes close to being a parody of the literary novel, overloaded with past guilt and death. Nickel Mountain, by the same author, remains one of my favorites. ( )

No one but John Gardner could take the disputes of an aging brother and sister and spin it into a major lesson about Life.

One very cool aspect of this book is that there's a cheap novel (read by the sister) within this literary masterpiece :-) ( )