I really liked this book. Like others, I didn't know women weren't allowed to play in orchestras. I predicted that Rebekah would play the solo in the performance, but I didn't know she would do it behind the stage. This was a book I could hardly put down. If I ever get to Nashville, I hope to see Belmont Mansion. ( )

A lovely and attention keeping story telling the plight of women musicians and their plight to be allowed to play in a orchestra which at those times the privilege was only given to men. A little suspense, A little glamour and a lot of grace brings this novel to a delightful conclusion.

Wonderfully compelling, insightful, and masterfully described. This book gave me a deeper appreciation for the musicians I know and love, especially my own daughter who is talented as a violinist but also plays other instruments. The plot was beyond what I expected, and so many times I found myself crying over different circumstances I could relate to, they were so real. This book was true to the adage of saving the best for last, to complete the Belmont trilogy. Definitely a must-read! ( )

This is a wonderful addition to the Belmont Mansion series. I laughed and cried in this story. I did not know that women were not allowed to play in the symphony at that time. I really hated the reason that they give for not allowing them to play. I am so glad to live in this time. Rebekah wants to play in the orchestra. . She hopes that maybe Nathaniel Tate Whitcomb who is the new orchestra leader for Nashville will be more liberal. These characters are very good. They are both very strong people. I received a copy of this book from Bethany House for a fair and honest opinion that I gave of my own free will. ( )

Oh my goodness! What a wonderful story. This book has cemented Tamera Alexander as one of my favorite authors.

One thing that I love about historical fiction is when I learn something interesting. I did not know that at one time women were not encouraged to play the violin. It was considered a manly instrument and men were allowed to perform on stage. Really? Wow! I am so grateful for the women who paved the way for me to have had the experience of playing the violin on stage in an orchestra.

The love story between Tate and Rebekah begins on a "sour note." (Pun intended.) Really it was a miscommunication of intent, but I loved Rebekah's gumption and willingness to put herself in uncomfortable situations to go after her dream.

The way their past unfolds and their secrets revealed was well written. This story is great from start to beginning. This is the third book in a series. Characters from the previous two are mentioned, but this book can be read as a stand alone.

The book contains Christian themes, non-graphic violence, non-graphic sexual assault, and kissing.

Source: I received a complimentary copy of the book from Bethany House to review. ( )