Excellent review of this aspect of Churchill. At times it becomes a bit of a hagiography, btu there's also a degree of balance. Definitely worth a read. ( )

I've never been that interested in reading about Churchill even though I eagerly consume most books about WWII... so I wasn't expecting to like this book. However, I was surprised to find that I really enjoyed listening to this book - well, at least the first half. The early life and WWI chapters were quite interesting - Churchills upbringing as basically a spoiled brat and his self-centered childhood explain a lot. The later chapters (WWII era) were somewhat repetitious, and repetitious on the most minor of details, and so I found myself struggling to keep interested.

Overall, I recommend this book for anyone looking to add breadth to their WWII knowledge; it actually is crucial to learn about Churchill to understand the war. It's not the best book, and it dragged in the later chapters, but even with all that I think it was a good overall book about W.C. ( )

I cringed my way though this book because of the redundancies, mixed metaphors, and other varieties of clunky writing that crop up on just about every page. Oh, for an editor! When I got to the end, however, I had to recognize the value of d'Este's thorough research and mature judgment. A definite keeper despite itself.

I listened to the audio book, narrated by Tom Weiner. The repetitiousness mentioned in other reviews is much easier to get through if you're doing something else while listening to the book being read to you, so I think it's a good choice for this particular book (assuming you don't want to check references). Even at that, I was ready to give up by the middle of 1943 when Churchill has his umpteenth argument with Eisenhower over the D-Day invasion. Still there was much that Churchill tried (unsuccessfully) to do at the end of the war to curb Stalin that made it worth reading to the end.

This was not the first book on Churchill that I'd read, so I appreciated the focus on the military matters. If your primary interest in Churchill is military, you'll be fine reading this alone, as it touches on most of the other major aspects of his life. If, however, you are looking for a well-rounded biography, you should look elsewhere.

Tom Weiner read very well and did a good imitation of Churchill when Churchill was being quoted. ( )

Overall, I did enjoy this book, but D'Este has a habit of superlative saturation -- e.g. how many times can Churchill face his most trying episode of the war (I'll give you a hint, it's more than once). Also, there were more than a handful of distracting technical errors: incorrect captions, repeated words, misdirecting index. There is even a line where all of the spaces have been removed to form one superword. But one the whole, a well-written and reasoned book. ( )