Foto de l'autor

Per altres autors anomenats James W. Thomas, vegeu la pàgina de desambiguació.

3 obres 100 Membres 3 Ressenyes

Obres de James W. Thomas


Coneixement comú



Does what it says on the tin. Thomas divides each book into sections (three or four chapters) and discusses things that strike him as worth noting on a reread. Given the nature of the book, the discussions abound with spoilers for the whole series throughout, which allows Thomas to discuss the series as a whole if need be at any given point. He returns to a number of different topics, including punning/word play, use of humor, fore- and aft-shadowing (events, dialogue, or references that both foreshadow something to come and look back to something that already happened), writing style, Christian symbolism, and the ways the books "grow up." For someone who has already reread the series something like five times, a number of Thomas's points are things I've already noticed, but there was still a fair bit of stuff I hadn't (and it's fun to read about those things I already knew). I read the section about HP4 immediately after finishing reading it then read the rest of the book straight through. Having done that, I think the best way to read this if you really want the most out of it, would be to read each of Thomas's sections on each book then read that part of the book (so, read what he has to say about the first chapters of HP1 then read those chapters). This book absolutely passes my ultimate test for this sort of thing: it makes me want to read the books again.… (més)
lycomayflower | Hi ha 2 ressenyes més | May 31, 2016 |
I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Having read all the Harry Potter books it's nice to know what subtleties I may have missed first time around, and what I should look out for during the inevitable rereads.

James W. Thomas' tone throughout is light and conversational. I never felt bogged down by descriptions or bored by his discussions, as can quite often be the case when people go about dissecting books.

Simply put, if you're planning on picking up your Potter books again, read this book first. It will enhance the experience.… (més)
K.Llewellin | Hi ha 2 ressenyes més | Jul 7, 2013 |
I'll give it a three, but I really didn't care for the constant focus on puns... Considering that of the academic Harry Potter books I've read, this is the first one by a professor, I expected this to be the most academic, and in reality I thought it was the least... Most of the stuff mentioned could have been brought up in any online readthrough of the books by non-academics.
YoungGeekyLibrarian | Hi ha 2 ressenyes més | Dec 30, 2010 |


½ 3.3

Gràfics i taules