5B

When Mandy Cobane was shown the photograph of her dead child, she said, ‘Why? Why would she…..?’, who did you initially think ‘she’ was?

My first thought was Mrs Saifre, then I rejected my idea as I did not see her committing murder herself, having it done yes, but not personally doing it. The only other "she" that came to mind was Sheila Begbie.

I’m thinking that “she” could be Shiela Begbie.

I assumed it was Mrs Saifre.

Sheila Begbie would be my guess also

Sheila.