3.5 stars. This is definitely as sad as it's hyped up to be. Beautifully written and poignant. However, the last half of the book was a slog for me. Everything from Troy-onward is pretty bleak, and Achilles frankly is kind of a jerk. Patroclus deserved better. ( )

DNF because I couldn't really get into the story(wrong time for me to read this). It is well written and will probably try again sometime.

Beautiful and sad and poetic all at once, my heart ( )

**4.5 stars** This is such a gorgeously devastating story. The prose is so well done and descriptive. The retellings are familiar and informative at the same time. The love between the characters is so present and everlasting. I truly loved this book. ( )

3.5 Stars

Unpopular opinion alert!

Chosen for a specific reading challenge, admittedly, this isn’t my typical reading fare as Greek mythology and the arrogant gods who love to meddle, as well as this being a tragedy doomed from the start, will never be my first choice.

Vivid in its rendering of one destined for greatness, Gods touched for the promise of glory but with such a promise, there’s always a steep price. Ultimately, there's no glory here. Achilles may be remembered for eternity but wasting a decade fighting a pointless war only to succumb and fall was quite pointless to me.

Regardless, I do see what all the fuss is about. This is no doubt a beautifully written book, rich with nuance and a detailed retelling of the doomed Patroclus and his equally doomed Achilles. The story between these two stands the test of time as their love is loyal, devoted, and unwavering, despite any and all (including fate and prophecy) that conspire against them.

I appreciate this for what it is, and I’m not surprised that it has won many accolades and awards. Miller obviously has a way with words but when it comes down to it, ultimately for me, this was just not personally enjoyable despite the stellar, talented prose.

( )